Episode 7: The Two Exits
The Sound: Mystery of Havana Syndrome 6 Mar 2023 33 min 4,198 words
Nicky Woolf (00:00):
Havana feels like a time capsule. I know, I know, that's what everyone says. But it's my first time here. Driving in, we're passing all these Detroit classics: massive Oldsmobile Super 88s, Plymouth Furies, and Pontiac Bonnevilles. All gleaming, brightly coloured, and meticulously maintained. Yeah. I love it immediately. I can't believe we're finally here. We're staying in a quiet central neighbourhood where Art Deco houses and apartment buildings line wide avenues. Some of them are restored and brightly painted, others so tumble-down it seems miraculous they're still standing. The roots of ancient trees crack and lift the paving stones. Beyond them, the skyline is dominated by massive brutalist housing blocks. It's dusk by the time we drop off our luggage and relax for a bit. "Nah, we're fine." Once we're settled, we head out to explore. It's a short walk down towards the Malecón, the broad esplanade that runs along the seafront. It's windy, and out at sea storm clouds are boiling on the horizon. And then suddenly, as we round a corner, there it is.
Max Johnston (01:20):
That's the embassy. There it is.
Nicky Woolf (01:23):
Yeah, where it all began. My producer Max and I have spent so long obsessing over this building, looking at pictures of it, thinking about it, talking to the people who worked here, seeing it in person. We find ourselves getting weirdly giddy.
Max Johnston (01:41):
Would you call it a 7-story edifice that squats like a tombstone?
Nicky Woolf (01:47):
For the backdrop for a spy thriller, it certainly looks the part. We asked Boris, our fixer on the ground, if we can take a closer look.
Max Johnston (01:56):
Do you mind if we walk around the embassy a little bit?
Nicky Woolf (01:58):
Yeah. We wander closer until we're directly across the street.
Max Johnston (02:01):
I was gonna say, it really is quite ominous.
Nicky Woolf (02:04):
Yeah. And we're standing, we realize, exactly where Kevin Coats told us about getting hit
Kevin Coats (02:10):
We were actually just outside the embassy, and when we started hearing the sound again, we started walking across the street, and the sound stopped.
Max Johnston (02:23):
Oh yeah. So that means they were—
Nicky Woolf (02:25):
Here. Where we're standing. Where we're standing. Yeah. Distracted, it takes us both a while to clock that we've attracted some attention. Two guards by the gates are staring at us. Another is quietly approaching from a side street. Yeah, we're about to get a talking to. Our giddiness fades considerably. We actually don't have our press passes yet.
Max Johnston (02:51):
Yeah, we can bounce.
Nicky Woolf (02:52):
Yeah, let's not antagonize them while we're still trying to persuade them for shit. And we're suddenly uncomfortably aware that we're holding some quite complicated-looking electronic equipment. One of our mics has a handgrip which makes it look, it now occurs to me, quite weapon-ish. We start backing away but more guards, or maybe police, we don't know, have turned up behind us now too. Some are in uniform, some not. Several of them are now arguing with Boris. Occasionally they gesture at us. Others stand around watching with stony-eyed caution. They don't seem particularly angry, but it's also clear we aren't free to go. They ask for our passports. Then one of the plainclothes guys, who seems to be at least vaguely in charge, gestures for us to accompany him into a low concrete building across the street. He points at Max and the recorder and tells him, to turn it off. From Project Brazen and PRX, this is The Sound. I'm Nicky Woolf. Chapter 7: The Two Exits. For 2 mildly tense hours, we wait inside a sort of ad hoc police station. Around us, officials pore over our passports and equipment, make phone calls, and occasionally ask us the odd question. They're polite. Friendly, even. That said, some of them are acting nervous. One asks to see our recorder. Max passes it to him and he prods it a little bit, then asks him to switch it on. The sound you're hearing is a Cuban official snapping his fingers over the microphone. He's satisfied. Then, abruptly, we're released. The official who seems to be in charge even apologises to us as we leave. Afterwards, Boris debriefs us over mojitos.
Boris Crespo (05:18):
So the policeman approached us. What were we doing in front of the building? And then the second he was wondering is your recording device and the microphone.
Nicky Woolf (05:30):
It was our equipment that raised red flags.
Boris Crespo (05:33):
They were wondering if there was some kind of interference between our recording device and their walkie-talkies.
Max Johnston (05:42):
So they literally thought we may have been there to sabotage
Boris Crespo (05:45):
Something like that?
Max Johnston (05:46):
The embassy?
Nicky Woolf (05:48):
The guys without uniforms?
Boris Crespo (05:50):
People that belongs to the Cuban secret police. They're not policemen.
Max Johnston (05:53):
Those are the plain clothes?
Boris Crespo (05:54):
The plain clothes, the civilians. They belong to the Cuban equivalent to Homeland Security.
Nicky Woolf (06:10):
So tensions around the US Embassy clearly remain sky-high. This is not exactly surprising, of course, given the circumstances. Like, you've got this kind of nervousness, like you've got these different layers. You've got the secret police, you've got the ordinary police, you've got the private security, you've got US Marines, and then suddenly people start throwing around this thing of You know, there is an attack. You can see how that's, you know, makes an already quite tense situation fucking nuts. Yeah. Yeah. We're a few blocks from the embassy at the Hotel Nacional de Cuba, the most famous hotel in the city. The walls of the bar are plastered with pictures of the celebrities who've stayed here. Winston Churchill. Paris Hilton. Mahmoud Ahmadinejad. Kevin Costner. But we're here because this is one of the crime scenes in our story. All our reporting ties back to places like this. The various pockets of Havana where Americans got sick. Coming to these places should help us sort the impossible from the possible. At this point, I think one of two things happened here. Either these victims were hit, likely as part of some intelligence activity, a surveillance or harassment operation involving directed energy like microwaves. And the second is that this all can be explained away as a psychogenic panic. In that scenario, Havana Syndrome is part of an American political agenda. The Trump administration wanted to brutalize Cuba, and this gave them a pretext to do it. During our stay in Havana, we'll try to sort this all out. Alright, remember Doug Ferguson from the State Department? He first heard the sound in his backyard.
Doug Ferguson (08:00):
Well, we started hearing this sound at our house. We were out on that back patio, and it was so loud that we couldn't talk.
Nicky Woolf (08:11):
That's where Doug makes that recording of what he heard. Here's a bit.
Doug Ferguson (08:22):
And I say, "Ah, it's just a crazy loud cicada, isn't it?" And they're like, "No way is that a cicada." 'Cause it is too loud and mechanical sounding. It was like a steady tone that just didn't let up.
Nicky Woolf (08:38):
Ah, the cricket cicada thing. I did say it was awkward, didn't I? It's frustrating. A detail that's gotten stuck between the teeth of this story, resisting all efforts to dislodge it. Still, when we ask Boris to take us cricket hunting, we're mostly joking. ¡Ya, vamos! ¡Vamos! ¡Vamos! Now we're in Miramar, a cushy neighborhood of Havana where many of the diplomats and expats live. It's early evening, and Boris is giving us a tour of the American residences. This gorgeous house. Wait, is it— is it this?
Max Johnston (09:14):
There's a security staff in the driveway.
Nicky Woolf (09:18):
I've been trying to work out the angles. Which buildings could you get to from other buildings? How secret around here could you really keep something?
Max Johnston (09:27):
I mean, you have to think this would be one of the most heavily watched and surveilled parts of the city.
Nicky Woolf (09:33):
Yeah, it's like it sort of brings it clear that it's like, you know, you know, a house on a street with, like, people coming and going. Just like it's helpful to put a face to a name, it's good to see the actual places where it happened. When I imagine Doug Ferguson's house, I've been thinking of American suburbia. White picket fence sort of thing. The reality is different. These houses are large, low, and widely spaced. Some sat in their own walled compounds. The first we visit has security guards out front, just like the embassy does. The second is huge and takes up nearly an entire block. The last home we see is right by the water. There's a rundown vacant building next door. The sun has set, but before we're done for the day, we want to get some Havana B-roll. The ambient sound of the city. I just want to get, like, a— yeah, like a— minutes-long sort of soundscape. So we're already recording when we hear it. It's quiet, but unmistakable. We creep across the street to where it seems to be coming from. Now we're in the grass just a few yards from the Diplomatic House. The sound gets louder. Max and I haven't said a word, but our eyes are wide. It gets louder and louder with each step. Through the headphones, it feels like we're standing right on top of the noise. And then it stops.
Max Johnston (11:17):
What the— That was fucking— I mean—
Nicky Woolf (11:20):
We're looking at each other in amazement. Max turns to the others. We've got Boris with us and also producers Javier and Nick. It starts again.
Max Johnston (11:30):
You guys just heard—
Nicky Woolf (11:36):
God, Max snaps the headphones off. Like, that is fucking loud.
Max Johnston (11:42):
That is like, right, jarringly similar to the recordings that Yes.
News clip (11:49):
We're now getting our first listen to what's believed to be a sonic attack against US diplomats working in Cuba.
Doug Ferguson (11:54):
I'll play it for you so you can hear.
News clip (11:58):
Shrieking crickets with an electronic twang.
Max Johnston (12:03):
That is— That's the sound.
Nicky Woolf (12:05):
We look at Javier, who grew up in Havana.
Max Johnston (12:09):
Does that sound like a normal cricket to you guys?
Javier Labrador (12:11):
I've heard— This is normal?
Nicky Woolf (12:13):
Yeah. This isn't a new piece of information, right? But hearing it for ourselves, it is. I mean, it's really loud. It's mechanical sounding and directional. And it's right here, outside this diplomat's home. If nothing else, it's shaken me enough to want to go back and check my reasoning. So, all right, let's do the cricket thing. If nothing else, because it's been bothering me since the start of the show. Early on, we ruled out cricket noise itself as a cause of the symptoms. And I still feel good about that. Insect noises just can't cause brain damage. But here's where the cricket thing was always awkward. When Doug and Kate heard the sound together, first with a bunch of their neighbors, and later when they recorded it, that's not the Frey effect, right? It couldn't be. The Frey effect amounts to sound reverberating inside the skull, not a sound from outside it. So you wouldn't be able to record it. There's no getting around it. This bit fits with the psychogenic hypothesis. You can argue that the cricket sound didn't cause the symptoms—the headaches, the nausea—but according to this logic, the worried Americans heard it, which triggered psychogenic effects. But let's be as meticulous as possible here. The psychogenic theory still has holes. It can't explain some of the symptoms, like Doug and Kate's jerky eye tracking or Karen Coats' bleeding retina. Do I think that's what Doug recorded? Yes. Do I think that's what caused what Karen's going through now? You know what I mean? Like— Does this change the balance of evidence, I don't know.
Max Johnston (14:07):
I mean, it changes something, I just don't know.
Nicky Woolf (14:11):
And it's not just Doug's recording. Several victims recorded a similar sound at the onset of their symptoms. Here's one from Patient Zero, the first American official to get sick. Stunned, Max and I pack up our gear and get back in the car. We make a point to get back in touch with Doug once we're in the States to sort this out. But for now, whichever way you slice it, the cricket thing seems like a hugely unfortunate coincidence. And I really, really hate coincidences. This is such an unbelievably frustrating story.
Max Johnston (14:51):
We have, okay, we've heard this sound. It only makes this more confusing.
Nicky Woolf (14:57):
Yeah, I don't fucking know.
Max Johnston (14:58):
It feels like every time we learn something new, we actually know less.
Nicky Woolf (15:06):
We'll be back after the break. We're back.
Johana Tablada (15:17):
Who's going to make the question? You? You? What's your name? Nicky. Well, welcome to the Foreign Affairs Ministry.
Nicky Woolf (15:26):
We're sitting in a meeting room with Johana Tablada. You've heard from her before. She's a deputy director general at the Cuban Foreign Ministry. In person, she has a forthright energy that makes her difficult to dislike and impossible to interrupt. So the second we ask her about Havana syndrome, she's off to the races.
Johana Tablada (15:46):
Because the one that suffered the most have been the Cubans. We've been the one that have been blamed for something we didn't do.
Nicky Woolf (15:53):
Johana says Cuban investigators pored over these cases when they were first reported. They didn't have access to any of the victims. But she says the investigation was still thorough.
Johana Tablada (16:03):
Common denominators of the Cuban reaction has been, one, to take serious the symptoms. And the other thing that characterized our response was the willingness and transparency to collaborate. They reject that from day one.
Nicky Woolf (16:22):
In 2018, Johana went to Washington to plead Cuba's case.
Johana Tablada (16:27):
You've been blaming Cuba for something that you cannot demonstrate. And you've been taking decisions that are having a tremendous repercussion on US relations and also in the standard of living of Cuba for no reason.
Nicky Woolf (16:41):
The message was ironclad: no attack took place here.
Johana Tablada (16:47):
The Cuban hypothesis, that there was no evidence whatsoever of no attacks, not just sonic, but also no microwave.
Nicky Woolf (16:57):
Max goes straight to the point.
Max Johnston (16:59):
Do you think the American officials who reported the health incidents are lying?
Johana Tablada (17:03):
I wouldn't say that. I don't have any reason to doubt that a person that had a headache has a headache. What I put into question is that that headache was provoked by a deliberate action taken in Cuba. So I have no reason to question the integrity of the American officials.
Nicky Woolf (17:25):
That's when she stops being diplomatic.
Johana Tablada (17:29):
I have all the reasons in the world to question the integrity of Pompeo. And I have all the reason to suspect of Marco Rubio because he has, as a politician, no integrity. And I have all the reason to suspect of Tillerson because he lied. And I have all reason to suspect of Trump and Bolton because they've been caught lying more than one time.
Nicky Woolf (17:51):
The real villains for Johana are the Trump administration officials, those who used Havana syndrome as a pretext to do what they wanted all along: to crush the government of Cuba.
Rex Tillerson (18:04):
What we've said to the Cubans is, small island, you got a sophisticated security apparatus, you can stop it.
Donald Trump (18:11):
I do believe Cuba is responsible. I do believe that. And it's a very unusual attack, as you know, but I do believe Cuba is responsible, yes.
Nicky Woolf (18:21):
So to find out the actual impact of all this, we go to one of the foremost experts in US-Cuba relations. Raúl Rodríguez is the director of the Center for US and Hemispheric Studies. We meet him in his office at the University of Havana. Raúl used to come to the States often for lectures and conferences.
Raúl Rodríguez (18:40):
I haven't been able to go though since 2017. Really? Right. Trump cut me off. I mean, cut us off. Everybody here.
Nicky Woolf (18:50):
Before the Havana syndrome, Raúl had high hopes for the US-Cuba relationship.
Raúl Rodríguez (18:55):
There was a boom in Havana. Everybody wanted to come to Cuba. Even the Kardashians came to Cuba. Havana was a new place to discover that had been shut out for so many years.
Nicky Woolf (19:07):
The Obama administration had removed Cuba from the list of state sponsors of terror. That opened the path for all these diplomatic agreements between the two countries. It's all these changes that brought American diplomats like Doug, Kate, Karen, and Kevin to Cuba. But Raúl says The celebrations didn't last long.
Raúl Rodríguez (19:28):
A lot of people here felt that Hillary Clinton was going to win. And the feeling here was, if Clinton wins, things are going to stay on that path. Trump won, and immediately after winning, started granting the right-wing politicians in Florida the wishes they wanted.
Donald Trump (19:47):
We do not want US dollars to prop up a military monopoly that exploits and abuses the citizens of Cuba.
Nicky Woolf (19:57):
We know what happened next. At the end of 2016, American spies and diplomats start getting sick.
Raúl Rodríguez (20:04):
My first thought that, how was that possible? I mean, if anybody is not interested in doing things like that, it would be the Cuban government. Having an attack on US diplomats in Havana during the time when you're negotiating with the United States, I mean, it makes no sense to me. And I started to think, well, like, who would benefit from this?
Nicky Woolf (20:29):
That's when, Raúl says, the members of the Trump administration get an idea.
Raúl Rodríguez (20:33):
They found it more difficult to stop it unless they created or recreated this national security problem of Cuba as an adversary of the United States, which is an easy sell for many politicians in the United States. The minute you say, 'Ah, our diplomats were attacked in Cuba.' That's it.
Nicky Woolf (20:52):
So think back for a moment to what happens after Havana Syndrome goes public. The fallout in Washington, the embassy closure, Cuban diplomats expelled from DC, Cuba going back on the state sponsor of terror list. That all leads to more economic sanctions. Then there was COVID and the Cuban currency tanked. Inflation is off the charts. During our stay, we were paying tabs with bricks of Cuban pesos.
Raúl Rodríguez (21:19):
But I think the worst problem in Cuba is the demographic situation. A lot of young people are leaving, and they're leaving because they feel that they don't have better opportunities here. So they leave with their talent and their knowledge somewhere else, and they're going to have children somewhere else.
Nicky Woolf (21:45):
¡Hola! To see this firsthand, we go back to the embassy the next morning, press badges in hand. By the crack of dawn, hundreds of Cubans have already gathered outside. The week we arrived in Cuba, the State Department announced the embassy would be resuming visa processing for the first time since 2017. So the line stretches blocks from the embassy all the way to a small park nearby. Producer Javier sets the scene for us.
Javier Labrador (22:12):
The ironic thing is that in front of here, there's a funeral home too. So this park is called, like, the park of the two exits. You go out that way, or you go out the opposite direction.
Nicky Woolf (22:32):
It's quietly a dark sort of nickname. What it's implying is there's two ways of getting off this island. One is with a visa, the other is in a coffin. The park itself is a very small patch of grass, less than a square block, with a few benches and trees. At least 100 or 150 people are anxiously milling around. Elderly couples, families with children, young men and women. They all woke up well before sunrise to put on their best clothes, gather all of their documents, and come right here to wait for their chance to leave. The chatter dies down when staffers from the embassy turn up. It's 3 Cuban women holding clipboards. One has a megaphone. The crowd moves forward to meet them. The woman welcomes the crowd, then gives directions. She tells them to have all their documents ready. They'll be calling out the names to start to form the line. Ángel Castellano, Jorge Castro. We approach one woman in the queue holding a big folder of paperwork. She wants to get a visa to go to the US and reunite with her husband, who's already left Cuba. She spent the past year and a half going through the consular process. It's been slow because the embassy was shut down. She's heard the government was investigating some weird noises. But she doesn't know much about it. Javier asks her why she wants to leave. "El mundo, estar a la par del sistema y trabajo." To be part of the world, to be part of the system, to work, she says. America has a thousand opportunities for everyone. What someone sets their mind to, they achieve. She adds that she's really excited to be with her husband again.
Guest (24:42):
Gracias. Muchas gracias. De nada.
Nicky Woolf (24:48):
We meet a man named Eduardo. He's a bit older, in his 60s. Eduardo's son left Cuba for the US 15 years ago, when getting out of the country was much easier. Now he's here to petition for his visa. He wants to join his son in the States. Eduardo tells us he's heard the embassy was closed because of some "sonic attacks." Javier asks what he thinks about them. Eduardo takes a long pause before he answers. They sent scientists, they sent the police, the FBI came, the CIA came. They went everywhere, Eduardo says. And they traced it back to crickets. Javier translates.
Javier Labrador (25:43):
So he's from the countryside, so he have heard some, the little crickets. He said that they are very annoying, but not to make a A conflict between two countries.
Nicky Woolf (26:01):
I don't think it was the main reason, but maybe it was some kind of pretext, Eduardo says. Javier asks what he thinks happened to the Americans. Eduardo has heard of the sonic weapons, but he says you'd never find something like that here. We don't have the technology, he says. Then he points to an old building across the street. Its foundation is falling apart. There's paint peeling off the walls. We can't support that. We don't have the resources. You think we have the money for this technology when we don't have it for emergencies? No. In the first world, maybe. But in Cuba, Eduardo says, no. ¡Hola! In the first episode, we talked about the power of a name. And now this phenomenon called Havana Syndrome is forever linked with this place. A place where, for a brief moment, there was hope.
Patrick Oppmann (27:09):
You know, for me, there was kind of a whiplash of, you know, when did things turn so badly so quickly?
Nicky Woolf (27:15):
That's the voice of Patrick Oppmann, CNN's Havana bureau chief. We heard from him earlier in the show. Patrick's office has a roof with an amazing view. And he takes us outside to show us what almost happened here.
Patrick Oppmann (27:30):
So many Cubans had invested their life savings into opening up another Airbnb or opening up a restaurant, thinking that, you know, that it would just continue as it had been.
Nicky Woolf (27:41):
We look out at the waterfront, where the vast husk of an unfinished cruise ship dock dominates the pier. Across the skyline, unmoving cranes mark the skeletons of half-built hotels.
Patrick Oppmann (27:53):
It was American tourists who were going to these hotels that they were building, going to the Airbnbs that had been opened up. were filling the restaurants. And then overnight, it all ended.
Nicky Woolf (28:09):
And between all these monuments to an abandoned future are the human stories. Those are the Cubans waiting in the park of the Two Exits. All these lives that were upended because of this story.
Patrick Oppmann (28:25):
I don't know if many people will cry for that in the US, but it was sad for me to see, for those people to have sort of wasted their life savings on a dream that essentially, you know, died very, very quickly.
Nicky Woolf (28:49):
Next time on The Sound: Conclusions. The Sound is a production of Project Brazen in partnership with PRX. You can follow the show on Apple, Spotify, wherever you get your podcasts to stay up to date on new episodes. Do leave us a rating and review. It really does help people find the show. Unlock bonus content and immersive ad-free listening by subscribing to Brazen+ on Apple Podcasts. Subscribing will get you access to premium audio quality and exclusive reporting, including extended interviews from the show. The Sound was produced by Goat Rodeo. The lead producer is Max Johnston. The show was reported and written by me, Nicky Woolf, and Max Johnston. Executive producers for Project Brazen are Bradley Hope, Tom Wright, and Nicholas Brennan. Senior producers for Goat Rodeo are Ian Enright and Megan Nadolski. Mixing and engineering by Rebecca Seidel. Additional production by Emilio Polo and Javier Labrador. Original score by the fabulous Attacca Quartet. Additional music from Max Johnston, Ian Enright, Rebecca Seidel, and Blue Dot Sessions. Editorial and production assistants at Goat Rodeo from Isabelle Kerby-McGowan, Cara Schellen, Jay Venables, and Megan Nadolski. At Project Brazen, Mariangel Gonzales, Megan Dean, Susie Armitage, Francesca Gilardi Quadrio Curzio, Salber Lee, Lucy Woods, Siddhartha Mahanta, and Neha Wadekar. Our producer in Havana is Boris Crespo. Ryan Ho, the series creative director. Cover art designed by Julien Pradier. Series video production by Javier Labrador, Andrija Klaric, Giulia Franchi, Emily Chao, and Nicholas Brennan.
The audio is the record: this transcript may differ from it in small ways.
More transcripts from The Sound: Mystery of Havana Syndrome
- Introducing The Sound: Mystery of Havana Syndrome
- Meeting Nicky Woolf: Answering the Global Mystery of Havana Syndrome
- Episode 1: Jericho
- Episode 2: The Immaculate Concussion
- Episode 3: Speak of the Devil
- Episode 4: The Frey Effect
- Episode 5: The Great British Nuke Off
- Episode 6: A Silent Injury
- Bonus: Fresh Doubts out of Washington
- Episode 8: Hammers and Nails
- Bonus: Live from the International Spy Museum
- Bonus: The Music Behind The Sound with Attacca Quartet
