The Sound: Mystery of Havana Syndrome cover art
Transcript

Bonus: Fresh Doubts out of Washington

The Sound: Mystery of Havana Syndrome   1 Mar 2023   14 min   2,480 words

Episode page All episodes

Nicky Woolf (00:00):
I'm Nicky Woolf, and you're listening to a bonus episode of The Sound: Mystery of Havana Syndrome. While we've been crafting our last few episodes, some big news just dropped. A new report from the CIA and other intel agencies is once again casting doubts on the Havana Syndrome narrative. I'm here with Max Johnston, lead producer of The Sound, who's going to help break it down for us. Hey, Max.

Max Johnston (00:25):
Hey, Nicky.

Nicky Woolf (00:27):
So, yeah, just run us through what happened today.

Max Johnston (00:30):
Yeah. So today we got the results of what is a pretty vast interagency sort of investigation on anomalous health incidents. Havana Syndrome, you know, same thing. Anyone who's been following this story has been waiting on this report for the better part of the past 5 years. And it's probably the most comprehensive sort of intel review of these cases that we've seen so far.

Nicky Woolf (00:53):
And what do we say? How much of it is public and what do we know that it's claiming?

Max Johnston (00:59):
Well, so we know it's been, you know, what people who have been briefed on it have said and what reporters have got. So what we know is that this is the result of several different government agencies investigating AHI claims by some of their government officials. And it's mainly centered around a couple of different things. Were these people attacked? Were these sort of— did something happen to them to cause these health problems? Was a foreign actor involved, and was a certain form of technology, was a certain form of directed energy involved. And it does that by going through, I mean, at least 1,000 cases in pretty granular detail. And so what we know now is the results of that. We don't know the methods. We don't know the specific sort of criteria for how this investigation was carried out. But we know what they're saying publicly about it. And they're saying that pretty loudly.

Nicky Woolf (01:44):
Take us through a little bit. This is— this sounds like a huge revelation, right? How much of this is, is new?

Max Johnston (01:52):
So in a sense, it's nothing entirely new. I mean, the big new part of it is that it is, like I said, it is quite granular in how detailed it is. I mean, they've— the agencies have released, I mean, specific information like granular details in particular cases with examples of why they don't think this is some attack involving a foreign actor. One example cited in the Washington Post story was one person's headache, which was caused by a clogged air vent in their air conditioning unit, which in and of itself, you know, we could parse through the details on that. But the fact that, like, they're releasing such specific information on such specific cases is quite unique, as you know. I mean, many of the, the sort of the public-facing commentary on this is from the agencies has been very murky and very opaque. This is not that, which I think is quite— is, is quite unique. And just sort of the volume of it. I mean, this is quite thorough. They're giving out a lot of details. They're clearly keen on getting a particular message out there, and that is one of inherent skepticism. I mean, the whole report is essentially a thorough, calculated dissection of the public-facing narrative of this thing. The report, you know, the results essentially state that, you know, these people weren't attacked. There are other more sort of mundane explanations for what happened to them. It says that no foreign actor was involved and it says that no directed energy was involved.

Nicky Woolf (03:14):
And what's the response been from the victims?

Max Johnston (03:17):
So the victims, I mean, they are, they are sort of not necessarily surprised. This report has been rumored for years, but especially this past couple of months, people sort of knew it was coming out and they knew it was going to be skeptical and they knew it was going to be more skeptical than, you know, the interim assessment we had heard a couple of years ago than what, you know, the NAS study had sort of found. So the first thing, they're not inherently surprised. They do once again feel hurt and betrayed. I mean, this is essentially the bureaucracy that, you know, employed these people and put them in these circumstances where they did report these health problems, essentially telling them that we think this is something else. We don't think you've gone through something inherently difficult or traumatic. And so that's, you know, quite difficult. A lot of these agencies reached out to these victims ahead of time to sort of soften the blow to say, look, this DNI report is coming out. That doesn't change how we're interacting and engaging with you and our relationship with you. You know, it was meant to sort of, like I said, soften the blow. But I don't know how much stock you can put in that because the victims say, look, that doesn't line up with the reality. You can't, you know, sort of act as if you're treating us one way and then publicly say something else. But this also— the victims have been keen at pointing out and sort of questioning the way this investigation was handled and the way it was publicly postured. Several have told me that, look, we understand— and we being this larger sort of collective of AHI victims— we understand that not one thing explains all of our health problems, but we do believe we were affected. Something happened to us, including forms of directed energy and including stuff involving intelligence operations and including stuff that involves microwaves and radio waves. So a lot of their frustration is with this idea that, oh, the intelligence community came to one kind of broad overarching conclusion. When, as I think you and I both know, having gone through this for a year, there's not like one conclusion you can really draw from this. And so I think it's quite complicated. I think they're frustrated. I think they're betrayed. I also think they see inherent sort of flaws in logic in the way this investigation was carried out and the way the results are being communicated, which I think is fair.

Nicky Woolf (05:17):
What we're looking at with this report is ultimately an accumulation of case studies with investigating going into those. Does it look much on the, on the other side of things, on what we've been reporting on the US having and other countries as well having and deploying these weapons? As we've heard,

Max Johnston (05:41):
It doesn't wade into much specifics more than what has been already sort of, you know, stated publicly by the government on this position. But one of the sort of newer elements, or one of the more newsworthy elements of this report, is how concrete it is on the directed energy question. Oftentimes these intel, you know, agencies and communities, if they are dismissing these cases, they just say, oh, it's not— nothing happened to these people. But now they're saying not only nothing happened to these people, but specifically, like, no directed energy was involved, which is interesting and I think kind of unique in this context. They don't wade into specifics, as many people— as many intel agencies have avoided already. I think we know why that is, is because the sources and methods that are involved in directed energy weighed awfully close into how some of these intel agencies operate and the way the Pentagon and the DOD operate. And they don't want to sort of open that box. But I was surprised by some of the messaging here in that we're dismissing directed energy even though we know this stuff has been deployed, we know people have been injured by it. But for whatever reason, this report says that that's not behind these AHIs. I don't know what the gap is there, but there does seem to be a gap to me.

Nicky Woolf (06:52):
What are the— what's kind of in the interests of the DNI and of the US government to come out with this, this report today?

Max Johnston (07:01):
Well, they've been working on it for a couple of years. It's been rumored to be published. I mean, any day now for the better part of our production of the show. And so in a certain sense, I think this, this, this report was inevitable. I don't know if the conclusion was always inevitable. This was a thorough investigation going over many case studies. Now, I don't know the methodology behind that. I don't know how they compiled this information and, you know, how they chose to publish it. But, this thing has been worked on for a long time. It is sort of the, you know, children or grandchildren of, you know, interim assessments and what we've seen from the agency in the past. It's a little more precise and a little more honed, and I think much more cynical than some of those interim assessments. But I think the government's main impetus here is, one, I do think there was an investigative effort and this is their way to cap that off. I do think the hope is on the part of the DNI and all the intel agencies is that this gives the story some closure. I think this is meant to be sort of their signature at the bottom of the page, if you will, that, nope, this is not a global campaign. These people have not been affected by some scary piece of tech. Everyone can go home and calm down. I don't think it's as simple— I don't think it's as simple or as calculated as that, but I do think, you know, they're trying to put a stamp on this and sort of wrap this story up. And, you know, the story is making a lot of waves. and so I think shows like ours— I think, you know, the fact that this topic is back in the news may have put a little bit of pressure on them. But I think this report has been worked on for a long time, and I think they've they view it as a way to end this story, for lack of a better word. And I don't know if that will necessarily be accomplished.

Nicky Woolf (08:43):
Between, between like you and me, where does this land us with our reporting?

Max Johnston (08:48):
I don't think it changes much. I mean, this is, you know, this is a, a level of skepticism that's so detailed and sort of, like I said, loud that I think, you know, I read it and I was you know, quite taken aback by how assertive it was in its stance. But it doesn't change what you and I have discovered, which the reality is, is that this technology does exist, and it exists in many forms, and it exists in many countries. And we do know it's been deployed, and we have heard from people. And you will hear these stories in some of the, some of the last couple episodes of the show, of people who got downrange of this technology and almost immediately had this symptomology manifests. Now the key thing there is, can we prove a link between what these people experienced and this tech and the symptoms that manifested after? And that's something that, like, you know, I don't know if you or I will ever be able to do. But I don't think this changes much. This, you know, enhances the specter of doubt over this story, but this doesn't change the personal perspectives that you and I have heard from very credible people. But I don't think it changes what we're doing, and I don't think it changes the the doubts and the questions and the beliefs that I have that this is much more complicated than I think this, this report sort of lays out. So, Nicky, I don't think it changes what we're doing. I mean, I don't know. What do you think?

Nicky Woolf (10:06):
Yeah, I kind of agree. And what I'm slightly minded of is what we heard about the report that the State Department rushed out in response to the Moscow Signal Lawsuit. What this sort of slightly smacks to me as wanting to put a cap on the story in a kind of nothing to see here. Let's maybe all stop talking about it. Again, you know, it's a— we've, we've heard from sources that the DNI was aware of our show and wanted to— do you think this came out as a sort of almost answer to us? Is this the DNI denying our reporting here and the reporting of others that's been going on?

Max Johnston (11:00):
I don't think it's as simple as that because, like I said, the DNI has been working on this for a while. And, you know, it's— I've heard it was supposed to come out as early as this past fall. But I definitely think some of this is motivated by the fact that Havana syndrome and anomalous health incidents are back in the news in a way they haven't been in several years. I think that was some of the impetus and the pressure to get this out now. So, look, I'd love to take credit for poking and prodding the intel agencies into, you know, you know, doing something, having a knee-jerk reaction. I think there's a— there's an element of that to this. But I also think whether or not we made this show, this report would have come out. I don't know if it would have come out now. But I do think this was meant regardless to be, to your point, that sort of cap on the story. And also, I think you raise a really good point about the, the historical context for this. I mean, the reality is the narrative of Havana Syndrome has unfolded in a similar pattern as it has with previous similar scandals dating back to, like you said, Moscow Signal in the '70s, Gulf War Syndrome in the '90s, 9/11 first responders in the 2000s, burnt people who survived burn pit exposure in the Middle East. There's this tendency of the US government to send people abroad, send them to do weird classified stuff. They come back with health problems, and then they, you know, spend decades fighting these people to get clarity and answers. And I think there's a potential that this is yet another example of that in the larger context of things, you know.

Nicky Woolf (12:30):
After this, we'll be going back to our regular release schedule. And we'll be passing through all of this in the remaining 2 episodes. Stay tuned wherever you get your podcasts.

The audio is the record: this transcript may differ from it in small ways.

More transcripts from The Sound: Mystery of Havana Syndrome

0:00