Episode 1: Jericho
The Sound: Mystery of Havana Syndrome 23 Jan 2023 31 min 4,031 words
Nicky Woolf (00:00):
Brazen. It started in Cuba. The US Embassy in Havana is a brutalist a 7-story edifice of concrete and glass. Ringed by rusty security fences, it squats like a tombstone on the edge of Havana Bay. For the backdrop to a spy thriller, it certainly looks the part. At the end of 2016, something weird started to happen to people working here. It was the beginning of something, something seemingly inexplicable, something that snowballed into a huge, global, history-changing event. Something that destroyed lives and crippled a nation. And it started with a sound. There's an Old Testament story, the Battle of Jericho. The Israelites, besieging an impregnable fortress city, are commanded by God to blast the walls with mighty trumpets. Our relationship with sound is both aural and physical. Think of the inception— "Wah!"— that skips the ears and cuts right through to our hindbrain. The deep, enveloping, thumping bass at a club or concert. A sound wave is a moving wall of compressed air. You don't just hear it, you feel it in your whole body. That's what makes it intoxicating. It envelops you, shakes you. You vibrate with the music, become one with it. <LYRICS>Oh, the whole town—</LYRICS> But it can also be destructive. An explosion is the same wall of air as thumping bass, but much stronger. A powerful enough sound wave is a shock wave. A powerful enough shock wave destroys everything in its path. That's the duality of sound. It can create beauty or pandemonium. There is no actual historical evidence for the Battle of Jericho. It's a story, but one that sticks in the mind because it's such a potent evocation of that of sound as a weapon. From Project Brazen and PRX, this is The Sound, an investigative podcast. I'm Nicky Woolf. This is Chapter 1. Jericho. I've spent my career covering stories at the murky intersection of technology and politics, and I've seen some really, really weird stuff. But I've never seen a story like what happened in Havana. It's a story about national security, Cold War geopolitics, spycraft, classified weapons programs, and black ops contractors. But it's not just that. It's also a story about chaos. State Department says one thing, then walks it back. CIA says something different. The FBI says it's crap, then they walk that back too. Politicians join sides, pushing their own agendas. Doctors and scientists tear at each other's throats over wildly divergent theories. No one can agree on pretty much anything. Not on what's happening, not even if it's real. Or if it is real, on who could be behind it. And everyone is so sure they're right. Reporting this has been like running through an endless maze full of dead ends, blind alleys, and traps. Not going to lie, it's quite a ride.
Kevin Coats (04:19):
She was at the filing cabinet in front of the windows when she experienced the sound.
Doug Ferguson (04:23):
And it was so loud that we couldn't talk.
Johana Tablada (04:27):
This has been one of the most dark operation In foreign policy of American history.
Linda Birnbaum (04:33):
By the time we were asked to investigate it, it was way too late.
Frank Figliuzzi (04:37):
I mean, it's an act of war. I believe it's an act of war. I think this is an act of war.
Kyle Major (04:41):
We might have to build something a little bigger. Okay, I'm ready. 3, 2, 1.
Nicky Woolf (04:54):
First, we're going to look at how this all started. Kevin Coats met his wife Karen while serving in the Navy. They started a family. He served in the Gulf War. After the kids grew up and Kevin left active duty, they wanted a new adventure.
Kevin Coats (05:13):
Kind of a silly story, I actually learned about the process of becoming a U.S. diplomat from a car salesman.
Nicky Woolf (05:20):
The salesman was changing careers. And he told Kevin offhand that he was planning to take the Foreign Service Officer test.
Kevin Coats (05:27):
And I was like, "Foreign Service? What's that?" I went home and told my wife, I was like, "Hey, I think I know what we should try to do next." In 2013, they were hired by the State Department.
Nicky Woolf (05:38):
They were what's called a tandem, a husband and wife who travel to postings together. Their first assignment was Australia. But when they thought about where to go next, Cuba was top of the list.
Kevin Coats (05:49):
It was before diplomatic relationship had been restored. And so it was still a very mysterious kind of place, especially for Americans.
Nicky Woolf (05:58):
So when an opening came up, they leapt at the chance.
Kevin Coats (06:01):
So now I was flying over the country looking down. And yeah, it was pretty exciting really, just because of the mystique. This is Cuba. We're going into Havana.
Nicky Woolf (06:13):
Diplomatic relations between the US and Cuba had been tense for decades. Extremely tense. The Cold War never really ended there. The US embargo was enacted under JFK, and Cuba's been a pariah ever since.
John Bolton (06:27):
The government in Cuba, I think it's still repressing its citizens. I think it's still a threat to the United States.
Mitchell Valdés-Sosa (06:32):
So many years of hostility, of strained relationships.
Archive audio (06:36):
A tyrant who has turned a beautiful island into a prison.
Nicky Woolf (06:43):
But in 2015, soon after the Coatses arrived, the political winds started to shift. The Obama administration re-established diplomatic ties with the Castro regime.
Archive audio (06:54):
It is history in the making. President Obama is about to land, the first sitting U.S. president to visit Cuba in nearly 90 years.
Nicky Woolf (07:03):
Tourism and trade opened up. Families were reunited. Money flooded in. It was an exciting time. For the Americans, life in Havana was truly idyllic.
Kevin Coats (07:16):
Every weekend we'd get in the car and we would just drive. It was all just, you know, interesting, exciting.
Nicky Woolf (07:23):
They'd fall asleep to the chirping of cicadas, an ever-present feature of life in the Caribbean. And they'd wake to the sound of rooster crows.
Kevin Coats (07:33):
We'd go out to the Havana Club, the Malecón, of course. It was just so many interesting things, you know, person, you know, sitting on the Malecón on the wall playing a guitar, kids, you know, kicking a ball around, singers, old guys with cigars, guys sitting around playing chess.
Nicky Woolf (07:51):
They drive out to the tobacco farms.
Kevin Coats (07:53):
When you get an actual Cuban cigar, it was almost like smoking a chocolate bar. I mean, it was So smooth. Truly amazing. I've always, you know, said to everybody afterwards, I mean, Cuba was fantastic until it wasn't.
Nicky Woolf (08:11):
January 2017. Embassy life isn't always romantic. A lot of it is pretty standard office work. There's civil servants. There's consular officers. That's what Kevin was doing. There's IT people, security staff, healthcare providers. There's HR. That's where Karen worked. She managed the embassy's local hires—drivers, assistants, interpreters, translators, that sort of thing. But there were spies, too. There was a CIA station within the embassy. These officers operate in a grey, secret world, gathering intel, developing sources. It's highly classified stuff. The FBI, responsible for counterintelligence, had a desk there too. And all these people come and go. It's a big ecosystem.
Kevin Coats (09:00):
When people started, you know, disappearing, it wasn't really noticeable at first.
Nicky Woolf (09:07):
Kevin says it's common for embassy officials to go back to the States for a visit or get reassigned at short notice. But this feels different.
Kevin Coats (09:20):
I remember asking somebody that was working in the consular section, I was like, "Hey, what happened to this person?" And they're like, "Oh yeah, they've left. They got medevaced. I'm not sure if they're coming back." I was like, "Wow, what?" March 2017.
Nicky Woolf (09:36):
The embassy holds an all-hands briefing about what's going on. It's considered classified. Kevin and Karen go, but they aren't really told much at all.
Kevin Coats (09:46):
It was very vague at that point in time. It's like, "Something's been going on, but we don't think it's going to be significant. We don't think it's going to affect any of you, so we just wanted you to know because there are some people that are gone." And it was actually, in this time when my wife had her first event.
Nicky Woolf (10:06):
Karen works on an upper floor of the embassy. There's a bathroom down the hall, and to get there, she has to walk past a big window on the front of the building. She stands up, walks into the hall.
Kevin Coats (10:21):
But as she turned a corner, she heard this very high-pitched noise.
Nicky Woolf (10:31):
The sound is piercing.
Kevin Coats (10:35):
So the way that, that she's always described it is like a, a tea kettle, just like on steroids. That high-pitched whistle that was so intense that she jumped back around the corner. She didn't hear anything else. Karen is confused, so she starts around again and it's still there. But it was a super, super high-pitched kind of sound.
Nicky Woolf (11:09):
She doesn't know what to do, so she calls Kevin, then embassy security, who send an officer upstairs to investigate.
Kevin Coats (11:18):
There was no sound, you know, by the time he got there. We had kind of no idea what it was, and we were suspecting, thinking, well, maybe is this what everybody else has been experiencing? But it was very unclear to us.
Nicky Woolf (11:33):
That evening, she starts having symptoms.
Kevin Coats (11:36):
She started seeing some black spots in her vision, and it was just like, started off, you know, very small. by the next day, it was growing. The spot in her eye, you know, was getting, getting larger.
Nicky Woolf (11:52):
She goes to a doctor the next day.
Kevin Coats (11:55):
The ophthalmologist is like, "Well, your retina's definitely bleeding. I've only ever seen this when somebody has a trauma to their head, like a car accident or something." This is really strange because she's never gone through anything even remotely like that.
Nicky Woolf (12:11):
She gets flown to Miami where a team is evaluating a rising number of similar cases.
Kevin Coats (12:17):
They didn't know what was going on. They weren't sure what to do, is what it felt like. You know, there was kind of nothing that they could tell us.
Nicky Woolf (12:27):
April 2017. Karen gets treated for her eyes, but there's not much else they can do, so she gets sent back to Havana. But then it happens again.
Kevin Coats (12:42):
And she was at the filing cabinet in front of the windows. When she experienced the sound.
Nicky Woolf (12:48):
Once again, her head starts to ring. She ducks behind a pillar, it goes away. She leans her head out, it comes back. It isn't just a sound this time. There's pain.
Kevin Coats (13:01):
And in this case, she had very intense pressure in her head. She said she felt like her face was going to just blow off.
Nicky Woolf (13:14):
July 2017. It happens a third time. And this time, Kevin gets hit too.
Kevin Coats (13:23):
My wife and I were together. We were actually just outside the embassy coming back from lunch. And we started hearing the sound again.
Nicky Woolf (13:31):
Feel the pressure in his head.
Kevin Coats (13:38):
We started walking across the street and the sound stopped.
Nicky Woolf (13:45):
Kevin says he didn't feel any effects until later. But Karen is getting worse by the day.
Kevin Coats (13:52):
She'd lose her balance and she'd start to fall. She was not able to remember things. She's starting to now write Post-it notes for stuff, trying to— so she can remember what she's supposed to be doing. She's got them all over the office. She started having sleep issues and vision, the sensitivity to light. I'd go up there and she'd have the light off in her office because the light was bothering her eyes.
Nicky Woolf (14:20):
August 2017. Karen is medevaced out again. By this point, cases in Havana number around two dozen. Like Karen, they report things like nausea, dizziness, vertigo, insomnia, debilitating headaches, cognitive issues. And all of them say they heard— a sound. How did we get here? After the break, we'll go all the way back to Patient Zero. All right, we're back. Reset. February 2017, one month before Karen's first event. At the University of Miami, in the office of a doctor named Michael Hoffer, the phone rings.
Michael Hoffer (15:16):
And the phone call was, "This is the State Department. We have a problem."
Nicky Woolf (15:20):
Hoffer had worked with the government before, looking at traumatic brain injuries in the military. We're listening to him tell the story at a conference. It's how he came to lead the first medical investigation into the Havana outbreak.
Michael Hoffer (15:37):
And the individual on the phone told me about an individual in Havana who had heard odd noises, had felt some pain in his ear, and had ringing in his ear. And the next morning was dizzy and confused.
Nicky Woolf (15:53):
He's describing patient zero, the first person to report the strange sound and these even stranger symptoms. As one case turns into two, then three, then four, the government flies them in for Hoffer and his team to examine. This is where Karen was sent in March. Even early on, it's clear a concrete diagnosis is going to be tough.
Michael Hoffer (16:17):
We had to work within the time frame they were given to us. We sometimes only had the individual for a day. We couldn't get every test in a day. We sometimes, you know, only had the individual for half a day. So yeah, there are holes, because that's what happens when you see patients for medical care.
Nicky Woolf (16:32):
But he sees enough to be convinced that these people have been impacted by something. And when he takes MRI scans, what he sees really disturbs him.
Michael Hoffer (16:43):
We have objective evidence that they had an abnormality.
Nicky Woolf (16:47):
That leads, as you can imagine, to some pretty uncomfortable questions.
Michael Hoffer (16:53):
What caused it? Who did it? You know, why it was done? We don't know any of those things.
Patrick Oppmann (17:02):
So, yep, patient zero. We don't know a lot about that person.
Nicky Woolf (17:06):
This is Patrick Oppmann.
Patrick Oppmann (17:08):
Patrick Oppmann, I live and work in Havana, Cuba, and I'm a CNN international correspondent and Havana bureau chief.
Nicky Woolf (17:15):
He's lived in Havana for 11 years. His connection with this country runs deep. His grandfather was in Cuba the night of the revolution and, according to family lore, met Che Guevara a couple of days after. Patrick himself first came to Cuba in 1994, aged 17. And immediately fell in love with the place.
Patrick Oppmann (17:36):
It just gets in your blood. So it's a place like nowhere else.
Nicky Woolf (17:39):
Patrick's been into this story as long as any journalist has, anyone outside the classified or diplomatic world. Even early on, he starts picking up on some odd vibes.
Patrick Oppmann (17:50):
You're talking to some of the diplomats here. I could— I could sense a change had taken place.
Nicky Woolf (17:56):
This is early 2017. Patrick's asking his sources at the embassy about all the new changes, about how the US and Cuba are adjusting to the new diplomatic situation.
Patrick Oppmann (18:08):
I could just tell that the relationship was souring, and I'd even asked some of the diplomats, you know, "Are you guys being harassed?" and, "Oh, we can't talk about it." Some diplomats one time, you know, kind of tell me, "Oh, you know, sometimes we hear loud sounds." And did I ever hear any weird sounds at night?
Nicky Woolf (18:23):
We now know that the first reported cases of this thing are actually highly concentrated.
Patrick Oppmann (18:29):
Initially, all the people, or most of the people who were impacted, as described to me, were CIA intelligence officers.
Nicky Woolf (18:38):
That's important to remember. It's only later that staff in the rest of the embassy, like Kevin and Karen, start getting hit too. The symptoms, though, are the same.
Patrick Oppmann (18:50):
And they would feel general sense of discomfort, sometimes even kind of excruciating pain, sometimes that sense of pain with a change in pressure. They could sometimes hear the sound that sounded like metal grating, you know, sort of metal being dragged across the ground.
Nicky Woolf (19:08):
As we've heard, when they move away, it stops. And if they go back to where it's happening—
Patrick Oppmann (19:14):
It started again. They could kind of walk in and out of what they described as a beam of energy hitting them. And so they clearly felt, whether they're right or wrong, that this was something targeted, that something was being done to them. And, you know, that someone was essentially telling the CIA in Cuba to— it's time to pack up and leave.
Nicky Woolf (19:34):
At the beginning, though, it's a very tightly guarded secret.
Patrick Oppmann (19:37):
It was considered classified, and a lot of diplomats were even told they weren't able to tell their husbands or wives because they didn't have that kind of classification.
Nicky Woolf (19:46):
That's what happened with Kevin and his wife, Karen.
Kevin Coats (19:49):
She was told, "You cannot talk about any of the things that are going on here." You cannot tell the doctors about any of this stuff. This is all still sensitive, and you can't talk about it.
Nicky Woolf (20:00):
But everything was about to change.
Heather Nauert (20:03):
Okay, are we done with DPRK? Okay, let's go to Cuba. Okay, go right ahead. Hi, how are you?
Nicky Woolf (20:09):
August 2017, a few days after Karen Coats is medevaced from Cuba for the second time, the story breaks in the press. It becomes official when reporters asked State Department spokesperson Heather Nauert about it in a press conference.
Reporter (20:25):
So, do you have any update, I know it's just recent, on the diplomats and the hearing loss issue?
Heather Nauert (20:32):
We will not confirm the health status of any Americans, whether they're in Cuba, back here at home, or elsewhere. What I can tell you, we consider these to be incidents because we still are trying to work, determine the actual cause of, their situation. They have had a variety of physical symptoms. That's as far as I can go in describing that. We just don't have the definitive answers yet. This is an active investigation, and that investigation is ongoing at this time.
Nicky Woolf (21:01):
Nauert, who's brand new in the job, goes back and forth with reporters for a bit.
Heather Nauert (21:05):
Okay, are we— we're done with this now. Okay, okay.
Reporter (21:11):
Acoustic harassment stuff?
Heather Nauert (21:12):
Look, I'm not going to confirm or deny what you're saying. We've had a lot of leading questions here today. This remains an ongoing investigation concern, and I'm not going to get into that any further. Okay? I'm done with Q&A.
Nicky Woolf (21:27):
Things get a little testy.
Reporter (21:29):
Let me ask you this. Why are we just learning about this? This has been going on at least 8 or 9 months, and now we're just learning about this? Why?
Heather Nauert (21:38):
As a reporter, you're gonna ask me that question? I mean, goodness, you could have been down there reporting on this. Look, people started experiencing ailments in late 2016, okay? And think about it, when you have an ailment, you don't always know exactly what's causing it. Some of these things take time to investigate, in particular ones that are— people aren't certain what has caused them. We don't have all the answers yet, so I appreciate that you want to try to push me to I'm not going to create, you know, storylines for you that don't match up with the facts as we know them right now.
Nicky Woolf (22:13):
But here's the thing about storylines. Humans don't understand the world as a collection of random facts. We need to put them together, create a narrative to understand them. And then we want to give that narrative meaning. A name. At first, nobody knew what to call whatever was happening in Havana. Early on, embassy staff called it "the thing." Some of the media referred to them as attacks or "getting hit." Others referred to it as a phenomenon. Giving something a name is a powerful thing. A name defines its subject, in some ways creates it. Codifies it. When you give something like this a name, it turns it from a collection of events into the storyline we crave. And that summer, a tiny Intel blog gave this phenomenon, the attacks, the thing, whatever you want to call it, a supremely catchy name. A name that would be splattered on headlines all around the world.
News clip (23:17):
Mysterious sickness called the Havana Syndrome. Havana Syndrome. Was something out there called Havana Syndrome. Havana Syndrome. What we now call Havana Syndrome. The affliction became known as Havana Syndrome.
Nicky Woolf (23:34):
September 2017. Back in Cuba, Kevin's just started a new job as Deputy Head of the Consular Section. Karen is still in the US getting treatment.
Kevin Coats (23:44):
Yeah, once she was you know, was there, there's a little bit of relief because I felt like, okay, now she's there with somebody who can help her and help take care of her. But yeah, it was hard, and it's continued to be hard, quite frankly.
Nicky Woolf (23:58):
But now, though not nearly as bad, he's started to struggle too. He'll lose his train of thought in meetings or stumble over words he's used a million times.
Kevin Coats (24:08):
People are still having to tell me the same thing over and over again, and I'm like, This is really embarrassing. This is not how I normally am. It was concerning me.
Nicky Woolf (24:19):
There's also a literal storm coming. The Category 5 Hurricane Irma has formed in the Atlantic and is bearing down on Cuba and Florida. Kevin flies back to the States to batten down the hatches at the family home in Key West.
Kevin Coats (24:37):
Thinking I was gonna be gone like a week and then I'd be back.
Nicky Woolf (24:42):
He never gets to go back.
News clip (24:44):
The Trump administration announced Friday that it is pulling more than half of its staff out of the American Embassy in Havana. This comes after diplomats and staff suffered mysterious health attacks that caused minor brain injuries.
Kevin Coats (24:58):
They made the decision to put it on what's called order departure. Everybody was nonessential. Got sent out, including the entire consular section. So I never went back.
Nicky Woolf (25:10):
The atmosphere in Cuba changes completely. The skeleton staff that remain at the embassy are tense, paranoid, jumping at every sound. Hoffer and the other medical teams now treating Havana patients are writing up their findings for publication. The media are hungry for answers. Investigations start to crank up. The State Department is desperately trying to figure out what's going on. So is the Cuban government. The FBI has sent in a team of agents. And the CIA has started a top-secret inquiry. The story is just beginning. This season on The Sound.
Marc Polymeropoulos (26:04):
There are other incidents that do involve dozens of people that just haven't been made public yet.
David Relman (26:11):
These were cases that simply defied an easy explanation.
Robert Bartholomew (26:16):
My specialty area is mass psychogenic illness and social panics.
Linda Birnbaum (26:22):
We felt that it was likely that it was some kind of microwave-type radiation event.
Ken Jones (26:26):
You know, a lot of these people were having suspected radio frequency attacks, and I had a known RF attack.
James Schumaker (26:32):
I've had some friends who have died from some very strange diseases out of Moscow.
Nicky Woolf (26:37):
That's the sound.
Kyle Major (26:41):
Under absolutely no circumstances am I building you a weapon because people have died, but we could make a device of Some—
Nicky Woolf (27:03):
The Sound is a production of Project Brazen in partnership with PRX. You can follow the show on Apple, Spotify, wherever you get your podcasts to stay up to date on new episodes. Do leave us a rating and review really does help people find the show. The Sound was produced by Goat Rodeo. The lead producer is Max Johnston. The show was reported and written by me, Nicky Woolf, and Max Johnston. Executive producers for Project Brazen are Bradley Hope, Tom Wright, and Nicholas Brennan. Senior producers for Goat Rodeo are Ian Enright and Megan Nadolski. Mixing and engineering by Rebecca Seidel. Additional production by Rebecca Seidel, Jonathan O'Sullivan, Emilio Polo, and Javier Labrador. Original score by the fabulous Attacca Quartet. Additional music from Max Johnston, Ian Enright, Rebecca Seidel, and Blue Dot Sessions. Editorial and production assistants at Goat Rodeo from Isabelle Kerby-McGowan, Cara Schellen, Jay Venables, and Megan Nadolski. At Project Brazen, Mariangel Gonzales, Megan Dean, Susie Armitage, Francesca Gilardi Quadrio Curzio, Salber Lee, Lucy Woods, Siddhartha Mahanta, and Neha Wadekar. Our producer in Havana is Boris Crespo. Ryan Ho is series creative director. Cover art designed by Julien Pradier. Series video production by Javier Labrador, Andrija Klaric, Giulia Franchi, Emily Chao, and Nicholas Brennan.
The audio is the record: this transcript may differ from it in small ways.
More transcripts from The Sound: Mystery of Havana Syndrome
- Introducing The Sound: Mystery of Havana Syndrome
- Meeting Nicky Woolf: Answering the Global Mystery of Havana Syndrome
- Episode 2: The Immaculate Concussion
- Episode 3: Speak of the Devil
- Episode 4: The Frey Effect
- Episode 5: The Great British Nuke Off
- Episode 6: A Silent Injury
- Bonus: Fresh Doubts out of Washington
- Episode 7: The Two Exits
- Episode 8: Hammers and Nails
- Bonus: Live from the International Spy Museum
- Bonus: The Music Behind The Sound with Attacca Quartet
