Bonus: The Music Behind The Sound with Attacca Quartet
The Sound: Mystery of Havana Syndrome 24 Apr 2023 31 min 5,670 words
Max Johnston (00:00):
Hi, I'm Max Johnston, lead producer and co-creator of The Sound: Mystery of Havana Syndrome. And I'm here with another bonus episode of the show. Today, we're talking about the music that made the podcast come alive. Last year, we got super lucky to book the Grammy Award-winning Attacca Quartet, a New York-based classical music group, to compose the score. The result was all these haunting pieces of music that tied the whole podcast together. Myself and our lead audio engineer Rebecca Seidel loved using that music to tell this story. Today, you're gonna hear a conversation we had with several members of Attacca Quartet. We'll go over their inspirations for the score, and you'll hear Becca and I gush about how cool it was to work with them. Let's get right into it. Alright, so I figured to start off, but if we just go around, I guess we'll start with you, Domenic. Could you just sort of introduce yourself and say which instrument you play?
Domenic Salerni (00:59):
Sure, well, my name is Domenic Salerni and I play the violin in the Attacca Quartet.
Nathan Schram (01:04):
And I'm Nathan Schram and I play the viola for the Attacca Quartet.
Andrew Yee (01:08):
Hi, I'm Andrew, I play cello in the Attacca Quartet.
Max Johnston (01:11):
And Becca, you want to start us off?
Rebecca Seidel (01:13):
Sure, so we were curious if you've ever done anything like this before, like compose a score for some kind of storytelling thing, whether it's a podcast or a film, like what other stuff, if anything, have you done in this kind of realm before?
Nathan Schram (01:26):
I don't know, I've done like some really small unseen little commercials and stuff like that, but definitely never, we all write music, but this is the first time that we've written collaboratively in this way, which was very exciting and I think really successful in how it came out in the process.
Domenic Salerni (01:43):
Yeah, I mean, absolutely nothing like this before. Again, to sort of echo Nate, yeah, I've done some short either documentary stuff like, like silent film accompaniment, which is a totally different, animal. And, and in those sort of forms, you know, you kind of have a lot more time on your hands and you sort of can craft things this way or that way. But yeah, this was amazing to just kind of jump in and see what came out.
Max Johnston (02:06):
I wanted to ask, so sort of going back to the beginning, the first real start on this work, I recall with you guys was, I think it was a Zoom meeting that we had with several of you. this was really before we had done much reporting or scripting. What do you remember either in that meeting or just when we were starting out? What do you remember about this pitch, about this podcast we were making that sort of resonated with you? What parts of it made you think, oh, this is something we could do and we have a way of thinking about doing it?
Nathan Schram (02:34):
I've been thinking about what the Havana Syndrome sound sounds like far beyond this opportunity came up. I've been really fascinated by this. So for me, that was like, oh my God, That's gonna be us, like we get to make that, we get to— and then I was just like, well, what does it sound like? I kind of wanted to listen to the podcast first, which we didn't get to do before making this music, so it was kind of fun experiment and imagination. And then I remember it being like the most fun kind of musical project where the guardrails are very safe. Like you guys are just like, throw everything at us, we'll sort through it, which honestly for me, the projects like this, that's the most difficult is going through too much material and figuring out what's necessary. And the fact that you guys were willing to do that and we could just really throw whatever we wanted at the wall and see what was cool, what stuck, and just know that you guys were going to adapt it to the story in a way that would feel right is a real, like, creative opening of a dam. I mean, it's just like, okay, then we just get to do whatever we want and let the critical editorial process happen somewhere else.
Domenic Salerni (03:34):
Four kids in a candy store, 100%.
Max Johnston (03:40):
So before you went into the studio, after we had talked about just the basic premise of the show and sort of what we were doing, I sent you guys what I called sort of a shot list of like scenes, themes, characters, ideas, just as a way to— I think you had asked for like some precision in terms of what we were looking for. Do you remember anything in particular about that shot list and what we were looking for that maybe sparked an idea or reminded you of something or or anything in particular like that once you got into the specifics?
Domenic Salerni (04:08):
Absolutely. I mean, for me it was that there was sort of the shock value of a sonic weapon, you know, and then it was like, oh no, no, we're talking about real people here. And like, yeah, maybe they're doing clandestine work or like they're spies or whatever, but the thing that really got me was that there are career diplomats and civil service people and government workers who like can't do their jobs anymore, you know. And that really just touched me. And so seeing sort of all of these shots, shot lists, or themes in one place, for me, sort of this meta-narrative was emerging from that. And so that's where I think I was personally inspired to write stuff because I think one of the working titles was "What Spying Is Not." And it was this very kind of cartoonish, like, "Mm, da, da, da, ga, ga" thing. And I think that was playing into sort of the popular conception of what spies do. But then, like, for me at least, it was just like, wow, you know, not everyone is doing the kind of glasses with the mustache stuff. I mean, it's a lot deeper, and there's a much more interesting human story, you know, that's being told here.
Nathan Schram (05:25):
Yeah, I remember like being really excited about all the mechanical sounds and like the drama of the weapon and kind of this like very, almost sound design quality of writing the music. And I remember the first kind of internal conversation we had, Dom was like, okay, for this scene I'm thinking like, let's say something based on Shostakovich, this should have a Cuban theme that I'll arrange. And, and I remember being like, oh my God, I didn't even think about that stuff. And then he brought all this stuff to the table and I feel like So much of the cues that Dom wrote for, which were a lot of them, ended up being these super colorful, really useful ones. They were the cues that end up making the story come to life for me and really kind of take it out of Technicolor and into something real life.
Max Johnston (06:19):
Yeah, I just remember sending you that shot list and getting the files back, and I think you guys had even slugged each file based on like whatever naming or numbering convention I had done. And I was just shocked at like how you very precisely got exactly what I would like had imagined. You somehow just nailed it, like the specificity of it. I was just blown away with— and of course that means we could just— we knew exactly where to use it in the story. It's like, you know, it just fit these themes to a T.
Nathan Schram (06:46):
That is one thing I want to speak to a little bit, just because I think because our background is like 90% in performing, even though we all write music, our careers have been based on performing and interpreting other people's music, which a lot of times means like adapting it to an emotional story that we find is useful. And I feel like in some ways we were particularly primed for this opportunity where it wasn't about like, what's our unique compositional voice? It was actually all about serving the narrative signposts. And that is kind of what we do so often with classical music. We'll take a piece by Mendelssohn or something and say like, oh, I think here is when there's real, a real struggle with some sort of relationship. And it was fun to use those tools and kind of exercise that muscle in such an appropriate situation.
Rebecca Seidel (07:32):
Totally. And just to add to that too, from a sound design perspective, being able to pull from those different categories and moods, it just was so useful. So, you know, we definitely had our influences that we were pulling from when we were making this. We talked a lot about like James Bond meets H.P. Lovecraft, and we were curious for you guys if there were any influences you were pulling from or had in mind with these compositions.
Nathan Schram (07:56):
I was thinking about other podcasts a little bit, especially when I was trying to think of like the theme music or, you know, just what I wanted to hear in a story versus what I would want to write. What things would be interesting to hear over and over again as like a basis? What kind of like chordal writing you could do that you could write in a lot of different ways that would kind of remind you you're in the same sonic world, but, but still telling like a different emotional moment. There is a whole like sonic template for how podcasts are starting to sound, or there's an aesthetic, I should say, that I feel like I had— I was excited to tap into because I do listen to a lot of podcasts, and I know that that music is just very different in function from what you'd hear in a movie versus what you'd hear in a commercial. I really like The Daily podcast, and I love how they're always using kind of a similar thematic material but manipulating it so that you get different emotional effects or different— it kind of puts you in a different setting at any given point. So I know that that was a big aspect of it.
Domenic Salerni (08:51):
Oh man, I totally— I would agree. And just to point to one composer from the past who I think captures this particular mood, it's Leoš Janáček. If there's like a master of disquiet, it's that dude. I mean, especially his string quartets, but also like his operas. I just was subbing with the symphony. We're doing this Taras Bulba, which is this like crazy story, and it's all about like these guys dying in crazy ways, and there's a father-son thing going on. But like, and you listen to the music, you're like, how did he come up with this in like 1915? It's like totally wacko. So yeah, and also other podcasts. I mean, geez, like a nugget, you know, can then be spread across this entire thing, and it's like, it's such a great way of tying everything together.
Max Johnston (09:36):
Well, so take me through the process of just actually like composing and recording this. Like, so you get this shot list of ideas, take me through what that looks like in terms of pulling the ideas together and then actually recording it, because you guys, you sent us full compositions, you also sent us individual stems, so I know it was a pretty involved thing. Take me through the how it actually came to be.
Domenic Salerni (09:57):
Oh man,
Nathan Schram (09:57):
There was so much music we wrote for this.
Domenic Salerni (10:00):
Well, and I just, so that people understand, I mean, we got into the studio like in between a bunch of touring and stuff and I think the bulk of composing happened maybe 3 or 4 days before showing up in the studio. Because I think when that shot list came through, it was like, oh, OK, now we can really start honing in. And Nate had the great idea. Becca does a lot of collaborative compositions— Nate's wife, Becca Stevens. And there's this notion of, well, why don't you take the first 8 bars, I'll take the next 8 bars, so that there's not competing vision or people bumping up against each other. So Nate had the great idea of, hey, if there's a shot that particularly speaks to you, just put your initials on it. And so we can kind of clarify from there. And that was, that was another great way. Okay, great, I can only— I'll focus on this or you focus on that. So that was, that was a good sort of initial step, I think, going in.
Nathan Schram (10:46):
Yeah, it filled up pretty quick. I mean, I think we had like 20 cues that we all just kind of put our initials on, and we— once we got into the studio, it was just kind of like we just had a lot of different music, some that had nothing to do with other movements. But that's what was so great about this opportunity is that there's moments in the podcast that take place in very different settings. So it was appropriate to have very distinct music. And I remember thinking like, okay, we're going to really perfect this thing. But actually we ended up just taking like oftentimes 1, maybe 2 takes per cue just to make sure we got through all the music because there was, there was so much material. And even our producer who was working on this with us, Chris Botta, who did a great job capturing it and making it sound really good before sending it off to you guys. He was just like, what are they gonna do with all this music? He was like, you guys did too much, which is the scariest thing to hear when you're in the studio because you're like, oh no, they're never going to be able to get through it all. Which is why I'm so grateful for you all to, have sorted through everything and used it so expertly.
Max Johnston (11:51):
Yeah, I think we used everything. I mean, I can't think of one stem that we that we didn't use. Andrew, I wanted to really quick while we got you here. So the question I was asking was just the process of composing and recording the music. If you could just tell us a little bit about your perspective, your role in that, and what that meant for you.
Andrew Yee (12:07):
Yeah, it was sort of— I had a very sort of new child. And so, you know, at first when we're like, okay, let's just do it, pop into the studio, I was like, oh my God, like, what am I going to do? What am I going to do? And I know that the other 3 came in with these beautiful scores with like dynamics and, and thoughtful placement of things. And I came in with some GarageBand tracks and I was like, hey, can everyone just do this? And everyone's like, cool, let's do it. One of my favorite ones that I heard throughout the podcast was this one where we make this like clicking sound and that's where you you put like a bunch of the tent scenes on there, and it just— I just remember just like sitting actually in this room, my child's room, and just making these like really creepy, clicking sounds. And I was like, I hope this works. I signed up for this feeling, so I hope, I hope this is good.
Rebecca Seidel (13:19):
I'm curious, Andrew, so you just said you signed up for this feeling. I was trying to gauge just from listening to the tracks, like, who had what vibe kind of covered. So I'm curious, even not necessarily just for this podcast, but in general, do you feel like you bring different things to the table in that regard? Like sort of the more haunting side versus, you know, scene building? I don't know.
Andrew Yee (13:40):
Yeah, I'm definitely the haunting one. I'm definitely the haunting one in the quartet. Ooh, very, very scary. No, but that's what I love about the quartet is that everybody has has their own wildly different personalities. And I think the reason that we have so much fun as a quartet is because we're, I think, pretty good at encouraging, people to be themselves. From the sort of like Cuba-est Cuba Dom tracks that we got to like, you know, like The Haunting and like the amazing theme that Nate wrote. And like, I think it's just so fun. And it was— that's why it was really fun recording this, because we had such a short runway that it was really cool to be like, what can you do in 3 days? Go, you know? And, and everybody had no choice but to be themselves. Like, no one's like, well, what is it? What is everyone gonna like? There's no— there was none of that.
Max Johnston (14:35):
And so, let's talk about that theme. In addition to all the music that have served all these various narrative roles, like, the theme was so cool to us because I love like a good cold open and I love a good like sting, like a crazy sort of amped up way to end your act 1. And the theme just lent itself naturally to that 'cause it has this sort of building tension and this very sort of loud, raucous, you know, bah, that thing, you know, that we love so much. Tell me about where that idea came from and then the recording of it, because it was, it was just so cool.
Nathan Schram (15:19):
I think the actual idea came from you guys. I think there was like some inspiration from the opening track of our album Real Life, which actually Andrew arranged. It's a hallucination track where there's a lot of, Andrew did this great idea with a bunch of unison strings kind of doing this throaty kind of vocal technique. And I think someone said they wanted it to sound like that, or somewhere like that was the first track they heard and they were like, "This is the group we want." And so I use that as kind of the big drop inspiration of that same kind of technique of having us all in the same register, really wild vibratos, kind of like folk singing together. And then I think I, again, going back to kind of the podcast aesthetic and things that I've listened to a lot and have really made me feel things during spoken word, like, The Daily, but I was just thinking about kind of how, how helpful those techniques are, like cross rhythms, a basic harmonic concept that you can kind of hold on to and hear in other places, but kind of has its root in the theme and then can feel differently based on how we play it. Because I think that kind of really basic chord progression I used multiple different ways in the theme and then throughout the show, you'll hear it pop up every once in a while in different ways. Yeah, I think I wanted something that you could remember, that you could kind of— like, I've definitely done a lot of road trips where I listen to one podcast and my wife and I have talked about how, like, wow, we really hate this music. It's driving us crazy. It's so annoying. and then other ones that we were just like, couldn't wait to listen to again. And so we wanted to make sure it was one that wasn't— was memorable but not annoying and not, didn't grate at you every time you started it. I— the worst thing that could happen is having a theme song that made you actually turn the podcast off. So the goal was just not to do that, basically.
Max Johnston (17:13):
Yeah. One thing I remember about the theme in particular was, you know, so we had the, the full theme, so the full composition, which, you know, has this It's quite loud. It has this sort of bombastic sort of outro to it. But we loved using, especially as the season went on, just the individual instruments of it. So the viola, I think we used that a couple times. When we wanted to hit sort of a core thematic point, but we wanted it to be a more intimate sort of point. So I think like the end of our Cuba episode where, you know, you hear the impact in Cuba, and it's quite a devastating story. And so we use the theme there, but we just use the viola. So you're still getting sort of this touchstone, but you're getting a sort of a more intimate, sort of sad, reflective part of it.
Nathan Schram (18:13):
Just so you know, that is my biggest fear in the world, that someone is going to put a microphone up to me during a whole quartet ensemble moment and then play it back and be like, listen to how he really sounds. And when I heard that, I was like, what the fuck? I was like, you can't do that. I'm supposed to sound like I'm in the group. I'm not supposed to be like, you know, but I actually, I loved it. I thought it sounded really cool. But I thought that was so funny. I laughed very hard when I first heard that. But I also liked how you guys— I noticed there was like kind of progressive editing in the show, and I noticed like you guys were using more and more like filter sweeps on some of the stuff, which I thought was really cool because just in that moment when I was like, maybe this theme is a little annoying, you guys would add these effects and kind of process certain aspects of it that made me think like, okay, this makes it a little less grating of a melody. Especially as you start repeating it, and I'm like, no, no, just once is too many. And then you guys— but you, you guys were so tasteful with how you, you made sure to adjust the music to always be serving the story.
Max Johnston (19:16):
Yeah, actually, I want to throw it to Becca there for a bit because— so Becca would be the one who would take the sort of music and just really just go wild with it. So Becca, I just actually want to ask you, what did you do as the show went on and as we tackled different stuff to kind of morph the music to fit the palette.
Rebecca Seidel (19:33):
Yeah, it was definitely a progressive process. I think kind of my first pass at it, like in the first few episodes, you'll hear us playing a lot with the EQ and just kind of going from like high to low and just trying to kind of sweep through it. And that was a lot of fun. I had never really experimented like that with string instruments before. So just to hear that happening was really cool and like eerie and wild. And yeah, as we went on, I added some drones to it once in a while to kind of add another dimension. And I think it's episode 3, which is the episode about the theory that it's all in people's heads and it's the psychogenic illness. I kind of went ham on the theme a little bit and just added a bunch of stuff to it. And I was like, "Is this too much?" And Max said, "No, it's great." I'm curious, you kind of touched on this too, for all of you, what it was like to hear your music processed in that way. I feel like it must take a lot of trust to do all this stuff and then just be like, "Here, do whatever you want with it." So I'm curious what it was like to hear that played back.
Domenic Salerni (21:11):
Yeah, it was super fun. I mean, you guys had given us some of the stuff that you'd done previously, so we had an idea of like how you approach things. And I loved what you guys had done in the series on Afghanistan. Again, this notion of the build and then like taking stems and using it here or there. And so it was like, oh, okay, this is going to be manipulatable, I guess. And so that was, in a way for me, it was freeing. So to hear it kind of transformed into a new way, it was like, oh, that's super cool. I didn't, you know, I couldn't have imagined how it could have been transformed or Yes, it was always a pleasant surprise, you know, are they going to use what we— or is it going to, you know, have a little twist on it?
Andrew Yee (21:51):
Yeah, and I know it sounds corny, but like as an artist, I feel like after you've done the thing, you know, it's out in the world, it doesn't belong to you anymore. So I feel like every time I heard my music, sometimes it took me a while to like remember that I had done it. You know, and so I think that there's something really beautiful about hearing a piece that's gone through a process that sort of had nothing to do with you and like being okay with that. I think it's beautiful.
Nathan Schram (22:23):
And there is an advantage also to having written this so quickly, just like, okay, 3 days, no time to edit, no time to be critical, let's put it all on paper. I think in some ways it made us feel safe knowing that there was some like gatekeeper at the end that was like, I'm gonna make sure this sounds good. Because that's your biggest fear is that someone's just like, "Oh, they sent it to us. Let's put it on the air. Let's, you know, put it in on a record." And we knew that there was going to be someone at the other end saying like, "Let's not let this mess up our show." so that was comforting. And so when in fact it did not mess up the show, we were really excited.
Max Johnston (22:55):
Nice. So in addition to the music, you guys actually composed sort of these soundscape pieces related to like the sort of auditory sensation part of our storytelling. So, you know, we have these scenes in the show where these people are, you know, experiencing the onset of Havana Syndrome, and that manifests in that they hear these sounds, and, you know, it manifests in all these physical symptoms. And so you guys gave us these sort of concepts, these like musical pieces that— it was sort of music, but it was also just sort of like an auditory palette thing. And Andrew, you were mentioning earlier about like the creepy chimes and stuff. Tell me about coming up with that and how different was that from making a more traditional piece of music and making something that is designed to kind of stress a listener out? Like, how did, you know, what was the process for that?
Domenic Salerni (23:44):
Well, that was all Andrew, I think. I remember there's one time where Andrew just goes, "Hey Dom, can you just play a C? Just like, just give me, you know what to do." And it was like, so I sort of frantically like did this thing and it was just like totally an in-the-moment thing and wouldn't have happened if it was like, "In measure 4, please play a D natural," you know, like, so having that freedom to sort of just inhabit the mood. And I mean, part of it too is, I know this was a very compressed thing, but we did have— I mean, a fairly long session in the studio, so we did have that opportunity to play around. And I remember when we first walked in there and Nate said, "Oh, is that an ARP 2600?" or whatever the hell it's called from the '60s, you know, these synthesizers. And it was just like, again, kid in a candy store. It's like, "Oh, we actually get to mess around. This is going to be fun."
Nathan Schram (24:31):
That was actually a big reason why we chose that studio too, is because we knew there were a lot of like synthesizers and tools there that we could— and percussion instruments that we could use once we'd done our homework, we could kind of play.
Rebecca Seidel (24:48):
How do you all get in the mood to— like, this was such a, like we've been saying, such a varied kind of score. We have these really upbeat moments, these really creepy moments. Were you all just kind of going one after another when you're recording with such a limited time? Like, how do you get in the right headspace for that?
Andrew Yee (25:04):
I feel like being a professional classical musician is all about being able to jump from feeling to feeling and in a convincing way. And I think sometimes it's really straining on you, like, as a human being. I know that, like, after some concerts, if I don't have a beer in my hand within 20 minutes of the last note, I'm done. You know, just because it's like I've gone through such an emotional journey. And I mean, this session was very back and forth, but I think we're used to that at this point. And the studio is a place that used to feel like a very alien place where we would have to sort of be different musicians than the stage. But now I think the studio has become another home for us as a quartet. And I think that feeling of like What are we doing? Let's go listen. Is it working? Yes or no? And then making quick decisions is something that we're starting to feel better about.
Rebecca Seidel (26:03):
I know you all have been traveling all over the world, and so I think Max and I both feel very lucky to have gotten you all in the same place at the same time.
Nathan Schram (26:11):
It was weird that it worked out, I have to say. I remember when this project first came in, I was like, ah, probably won't happen. But I'm so glad, I'm so glad that— I have to say, yeah, Dom was a particular advocate for this, and I think every project with a quartet that's really democratically led, you always need an advocate in the group to push a project through because, you know, there's so much cool music out there and so many cool opportunities, and Dom really made sure this one was one that we all checked out and recognized that was worth it, and I'm very grateful to Dom for for helping us recognize how wonderful this collaboration was going to be, and it all held true.
Rebecca Seidel (26:52):
Well, we're really grateful to you all.
Max Johnston (26:54):
What's next for Attacca Quartet? What's next in terms of touring or music? What should fans keep an ear out for?
Domenic Salerni (27:00):
Well, I mean, we do have a lot of recordings out there now, and, you know, some of them have been recognized for things. And yeah, I think going back to this notion of how do you survive a global pandemic, and that brought us into the studio, into concert halls where it was just us and the engineer, or just us and the engineer and a videographer or something. And to sort of have these intimate moments through music, I think it's just a part and parcel of what a string quartet does, but also just what live music is about. And so to be able to play concerts again is amazing. But yeah, I mean, you know, we live and work in New York City, and so we're going to have some appearances at Wave Hill and at the Princeton Summer Festival this summer. And then I think we are looking at a pretty big Carnegie Hall debut. So if you happen to be in the city, definitely check us out. But yeah, I mean, get your music where you get your music, follow Attacca Quartet.
Nathan Schram (27:50):
Yeah, if you check out our website for tour dates, just to jump on what Dom was saying, I mean, we're going to be all over the US. Or in the summer, we're also going to be in California and Florida. And in the fall, leading up to some of these big debuts like at Carnegie Hall and stuff, we're going to be playing throughout the country, in the Midwest, in the South and all over the place. So if you'd like to hear, like Dom was saying, a more intimate perspective of the Attacca Quartet or a live perspective, check out our dates and you'll— I think you'll get something very different from what you hear on the podcast, but equally as satisfying.
Rebecca Seidel (28:21):
Thank you so much to the Attacca Quartet, or three-quarters of the Attacca Quartet, for joining us. This was such a fun conversation.
Andrew Yee (28:28):
So fun to be here. Thanks for having us.
Nathan Schram (28:29):
Yeah, thanks so much.
Domenic Salerni (28:30):
Thank you so much. What an honor. Seriously.
Max Johnston (28:41):
Thanks so much for listening to The Sound. For even more bonus material, subscribe to Brazen Plus on Apple Podcasts. Subscribers can listen ad-free across all Project Brazen podcasts, access exclusive bonus episodes, and binge brand new series before general release. And stay tuned for more.
The audio is the record: this transcript may differ from it in small ways.
More transcripts from The Sound: Mystery of Havana Syndrome
- Introducing The Sound: Mystery of Havana Syndrome
- Meeting Nicky Woolf: Answering the Global Mystery of Havana Syndrome
- Episode 1: Jericho
- Episode 2: The Immaculate Concussion
- Episode 3: Speak of the Devil
- Episode 4: The Frey Effect
- Episode 5: The Great British Nuke Off
- Episode 6: A Silent Injury
- Bonus: Fresh Doubts out of Washington
- Episode 7: The Two Exits
- Episode 8: Hammers and Nails
- Bonus: Live from the International Spy Museum
