Fat Leonard cover art
Transcript

FAT LEONARD – #3: Paula

Fat Leonard   7 Jul 2022   4,776 words

Tom Wright (00:00):
Please note, the following episode contains mature language and discussion about sexual assault, including against minors.

Paula Coughlin (00:14):
Even now, there are these strongholds of misogynistic military men that still want to take me down. Men that believe I ruined the military. One of my neighbors, former Naval Academy. His wife told me, "I've been praying a lot for you and I've been praying a lot for my husband so that he can forgive you." And I said— I mean, I know her from walking the dog. I don't know her from the Navy. I don't know her from anything. And this was just like last year.

Tom Wright (00:52):
That's Paula Coughlin, a former Navy helicopter pilot.

Paula Coughlin (00:55):
She said, "Well, I've been praying that my husband can forgive you for You know, what you did to the Navy. I said, I'm still not sure what I need to be forgiven for. And she said, well, you know, he went to the Naval Academy, and a lot of his friends did too. And they didn't make admiral because of you. I said, that happened 30 years ago, and I've lived down the street from you for 20 years. And this is how you initiate a conversation, that you're going to pray for my forgiveness?

Tom Wright (01:27):
Las Vegas, 1991. Hundreds of naval aviators were packed into a conference room at the Las Vegas Hilton. The previous day, 3 of the aviators shot down and captured by Iraq during the Gulf War had given presentations about their experiences. Everyone was in a victory mood. This was the annual tailhook convention.

Paula Coughlin (01:53):
Tailhook refers to the actual device, a little hook on the back of an aircraft. It's been in existence for, gosh, many, many years, since my dad was doing carrier aviation on a wood aircraft deck.

Tom Wright (02:06):
That Saturday, a row of Navy leaders sat on a stage taking questions from the audience. 40,000 women had been deployed to the Gulf War earlier that year, but by law, were not allowed to serve on combat ships or fly fighter jets. One woman in the audience questioned when the Navy planned to finally open the doors to female fighter pilots.

Paula Coughlin (02:34):
I was wondering, sir, when you plan to implement that and if it's gonna be soon.

Tom Wright (02:40):
The male jeering set the tone for what occurred later that evening.

Paula Coughlin (02:47):
I walk off the elevator expecting to meet my boss, expecting to meet other admiral's aides, people I know and people I've worked with. And when I walked off the elevator into the hallway, it's a big wide hotel hallway, but it's completely lined with aviators in swimsuits and shorts and casual clothes, all holding drinks. As soon as I made it to the head of the hallway, all the members, probably a couple of hundred people, close in on me, and this was known as the gauntlet. Once the call was made, Admiral's aide, the ranks just closed in, and I was sort of pushed, sort of pulled down the hallway while they tried to remove my clothes, groped, went underneath my skirt, in my shirt. I mean, it was just an entire gang of men attacking me, and I fought back. I kicked and punched and actually bit somebody on the forearm, and finally, probably 40, 50, 60 feet down the hallway, I'm ejected out the end. And I turned the corner and went into one of the hospitality suites. It was quiet there for a second. And sat down. And the Secretary of the Navy, his aide found me and said, "I heard you just went through the gauntlet. Why would you do that?"

Tom Wright (04:29):
The Tailhook scandal, 3 decades ago, is largely forgotten these days, but it dominated the media for months in the 1990s.

News clip (04:38):
Old stereotypes about sex-crazed sailors have come back to haunt the Navy. Charges of sexual harassment by women who say they were manhandled at a gathering of Navy fliers. It was called the worst case of sexual harassment in the Navy's history.

Tom Wright (04:55):
Women were assuming a greater role in the Navy. The first mixed-crew ships had supported the Gulf War, even if they were not allowed to take part in active combat. The world was modernizing, and women were fighting for equal rights in the military, as in other careers. Tailhook showed just how far the Navy lagged behind.

Paula Coughlin (05:13):
They had posters up in their hospitality suites that said, "Women are property." They had in some hospitality suites where they could invite women in and shave their pubic area and give them shots of alcohol. The mascot for the squadron was the rhinos. So they had a giant rhino painted on the wall, and women could come up and actually suck on the rhino's penis to get a free drink.

Tom Wright (05:44):
I'm Tom Wright, and this is Fat Leonard, a podcast from Project Brazen. And I've been uncovering the truth of the Fat Leonard corruption scandal. In which Leonard Francis, a contractor for the Navy in the Pacific, corrupted the 7th Fleet and became exorbitantly wealthy in the process. Our story and its yet-to-be-written conclusion shows the Navy still has not fully reckoned with its treatment of women laid bare by the happenings at Tailhook all those years ago. And that's because back then, as now, the Navy prefers to protect its own. Women had to suck it up, and those who complained, like Paula Coughlin, ended up being ostracized.

Paula Coughlin (06:30):
In the context of what you're looking at systemically in the military, Tailhook is a shiny, nasty little abscess that is a microcosm for the attitude that, I'm sorry to say, still is very prevalent in the military.

Tom Wright (06:48):
Well, that's what I was going to ask. The reason I'm interested in Tailhook is because It doesn't seem that there's been any improvement in the last 30 years. It's not exactly the same situation as what you're describing, but it's indicative of a culture that didn't change in the last 30 years.

Paula Coughlin (07:01):
Right. Well, it's— What the consistencies are: abusing women is a commodity. Whether it's at a hotel in Las Vegas provided by the Tailhook Association, or whether it's by Fat Leonard, it's a currency.

Tom Wright (07:20):
Paula Coughlin is different from other whistleblowers I've known over the years. During our video chats, she came across as smart and humorous. The injustices dealt out to her by the Navy haven't made her bitter. You sense a hardcore of resilience built up over years of men telling her she should have stayed quiet, not been such a killjoy. But she's able to look at her own story and the Navy's predicament with a detachment that's rare for people whose lives have been defined by an injustice. Can you just explain to me why you think women are mistreated in the armed forces? If you would try to analyze what are the core reasons, what would you say?

Paula Coughlin (08:03):
I spent most of my career before the Navy working in an all-male dominant field, and my observation is that when men recognize that women can do their job just as well, somehow that is perceived as diminishing the value or the difficulty of the job. So in order to maintain their stature and their— I guess their self-esteem— as superstar jet pilots or boat drivers or naval officers or corporate leaders, whatever position they're in, keeping women out of it because obviously it's too difficult or it's too technical or it's too physical.

Tom Wright (08:51):
In hours of my conversations with Leonard, he constantly played on this trope that Navy officers are somehow special, a cliché propagated by TV shows and films like Top Gun and NCIS. And Leonard explained away the wild sexual nature of these officers as a release from the stress they're under.

Leonard Francis (09:10):
Well, they're all warfighters. They have this inside— it's their psyche, you know. For them, is they have a lot of stress internally, pressure, you know. There's a lot of pressure with their jobs. This is the way the Navy operates. It's kind of normal. The military is always like that, that sex drive, sex-driven. That's why there's so much of, you know, sexual harassment, rape There's so much goes on in the military that's covered up most of the time.

Tom Wright (09:40):
I talked to Blake Herzinger, a US Navy reservist based in Singapore, about all this. From a Navy family, Blake was keen to talk, angry at what he sees as a failure to properly account for the Fat Leonard corruption. He's from Sandpoint, Idaho, all-American, in his 30s and well-built. We recorded in my home studio in Singapore, where he works as a business consultant.

Blake Herzinger (10:03):
It's a high-stress environment for sure, and you're away from shore for a month, and a lot of people cut loose when they hit the shore. People go crazy.

Tom Wright (10:11):
But the officers involved with Leonard weren't exactly battle-hardened. Although many had rotated into Iraq or Afghanistan, few had experience of combat like the Marines or Army. And yet, when they got arrested, many claimed PTSD, or stress from war, had caused them to fall into corruption and debauchery with Leonard. It's an excuse for which Blake has no time at all.

Blake Herzinger (10:34):
I mean, oh, I just don't have any pity for that person who is just blatantly engaging in corruption and then blaming operational tempo for all of his woes. No, buddy, you took your family to a hotel in Hong Kong. This was not like, oh my God, I've really been in the shit and now I've got to blow off some steam. You know, I'm not Charlie Sheen breaking mirrors in a hotel room. You know, you're on a nice vacation with your family. Martin Sheen, not Charlie Sheen. Wrong Sheen.

Tom Wright (11:02):
I agree with Blake. These Navy officers felt entitled to the sex, a perk of the job. And only after the fact did they resort to this self-justifying myth about the needs of combat veterans to blow off steam.

Blake Herzinger (11:14):
To say like, oh, well, these guys have really been in the wars and now they need to come here and engage in some sort of weird paid-for orgy in the top of a hotel in Manila. I don't know about that.

Tom Wright (11:24):
A lot of excuses have gotten thrown around in the Fat Leonard saga. But Paula has an explanation for how male Navy officers behave. And it's simpler and more brutal.

Paula Coughlin (11:35):
I would say that there's just this gray area where the military culture has always viewed women as second-class citizens, as property, as a reward when you get into port to rape and pillage. And that gray area occurs when what they viewed as property now is a coworker, or is supposed to be treated as a coworker, and make the leap from what we did in port to minors and women was bad, because, look, now we're working with women, and they have such value and contribute to the workforce. That leap has not been made. When I was attacked in the hallway at Tailhook, those people knew exactly who I was. They were chanting, "Admiral's aide, Admiral's aide." I became a high-value target. Not someone who's like, "Oh, wow, this is an aviator, this is one of ours."

Tom Wright (12:35):
Penang, Malaysia, 1992. The USS Acadia pulls alongside Swettenham Pier in Penang, a basic facility more used to hosting cruise ships than a Navy vessel. Leonard Francis, aged only 27, is waiting expectantly on the pier. He'd done some contracting jobs for the US Navy, but the flow of ships between the US and the Middle East during the recent Gulf War had increased, and that made Penang attractive as a midway R&R spot. The 1,000-strong crew started down the gangplank to the pier. Leonard had everything planned out in folders. Dinners, drinks, entertainment, touring, and shopping. The Acadia, an auxiliary ship, had repaired damaged vessels and supplied Tomahawk missiles to destroyers during the Gulf War conflict. After some time in the Pacific, it was heading back to the Middle East. But the ship was notable for another reason. It was the first ever mixed-sex US Navy vessel to be deployed during wartime. Of the 1,000 crew, about a third were female.

Leonard Francis (13:41):
We had a lot of ships pulling in at that time that were going into the Persian Gulf. So all the submarine tenders, or tenders as you used to call them, all the supply kind of ships were pulling into Penang those days, and we had a huge female crew on board.

Tom Wright (14:00):
By the time it berthed in Penang, The Acadia already was notorious, dubbed in the US media as the "Love Boat" after 36 women, or 1 in 10 of the female crew, became pregnant and had to be flown home during the war. For years conservatives in the Navy argued against letting in women exactly for this reason. They would distract men, they said.

News clip (14:22):
"I don't know exactly how these women are gonna handle this. I think this should be a—" A man's war here.

Tom Wright (14:30):
Senators and military generals, old white men, bloviated for hours in Congress about how women were not up to the task.

News clip (14:38):
The purpose of the military is first of all to defend this nation's vital security interests throughout the globe, and second, to ensure equality. So it's an extraordinarily high standard of excellence which must be met And you cannot have a dual standard. And in my judgment, you are not going to find very many, if any, other than males who can meet these kinds of stringent combat and related tasks.

Tom Wright (15:12):
But the tide was turning. Two years after the Gulf War, Congress finally allowed women to serve on combat ships. Ten years ago, they were permitted to serve on submarines, and 5 years ago they could apply for any combat job, although no woman has yet been made a Navy SEAL. Still, the women on the Acadia back then were in a male-dominated environment, and they were expected to play by the boys' rules. Paula Coughlin:

Paula Coughlin (15:37):
When you are one of the only women in the room, or the only woman in the room, or the only woman in the cockpit, there's an expectation of behavior to conform to norms of communication, including cussing, lewd conversation, bad jokes, whatever. You're part of the boys' club. I always felt like I am rough and tumble. I've worked around men in my whole career, and I can roll with a lot of the bad humor, a lot of it. I don't take it personally. But this idea that you're part of the boys' club is a fallacy. You're not.

Tom Wright (16:14):
Leonard, of course, sees it differently.

Leonard Francis (16:16):
Male, female officers, there's no difference. When they get drunk, they're so messed up. They're like out of control. Yeah, I had a good time, you know.

Tom Wright (16:30):
Of course, Leonard and his group from the Acadia stumbled out into the street and ended up back at a hotel. Leonard says he had sex with one of the female officers.

Leonard Francis (16:46):
I mean, you know, you got to do what you got to do. It's survival. And I was a bachelor then too, so it's okay. I wasn't married, you know. We're all just having some good fun, some good sailor fun. See, so that's why I said I was in bed with the Navy all the way.

Tom Wright (17:04):
Leonard makes all his sexual encounters sound fun. Innocent even. He knows he's being recorded for a podcast, but every now and then he makes a word choice that shows his deeper feelings about women.

Leonard Francis (17:14):
You know, another thing that the Navy covered up was they never wanted to charge any of their female officers.

Tom Wright (17:21):
We're not naming the Navy officer here for privacy reasons. It's hard to know exactly what went on 30 years ago, but we included the outline of this story for one important reason: to shine a light on Leonard's deep hatred of women. Which will become clearer later in this series, with tragic consequences.

Leonard Francis (17:38):
She was a bloody whore, you know. You just look at them, it's just shocking the way they are. Conflict of interest, sexual relationship, man, with a contractor. Oh Lord.

Tom Wright (17:50):
Leonard's misogyny, his gratuitous use of hostile language, perhaps started with his father, who battered his mother and had multiple affairs. But Leonard's view of women as sexual objects appears to have deepened through his work with the U.S. Navy in the years that followed.

Leonard Francis (18:06):
But it's really nice when they interview you, right? They ask you, "Oh, could you tell us, were there any, specific marks on the body?" You know, "Were there any mold?" What do you want me to do, tell her what kind of nipples she had or something? You know?

Tom Wright (18:34):
Navy defenders say most officers don't act this way, and no one doubts that. But it's hardly the point. The almost 30 officers who have been indicted for their involvement with Leonard were supposed to be among the brightest and best of the Navy. Take Mario Herrera. A commander aboard the Blue Ridge who is nicknamed "Choke," according to an indictment that will go to trial next year. What about Choke Herrera?

Leonard Francis (19:01):
Well, that is Mario. Mario Herrera liked to strangle hookers. So he used to, like, choke them until, you know, a lot of the girls went blue and they didn't want to see him anymore.

Tom Wright (19:15):
Herrera has pleaded not guilty to charges that include conspiracy. Then there's José Luis Sánchez, another Navy commander, almost as huge as Leonard, with a double chin and thinning hair, who sent regular requests for photos of prostitutes. Sánchez would write "yummy, daddy-like," according to an indictment. Sánchez has pleaded guilty to conspiracy and is awaiting sentencing. After orgies, Leonard regularly sent around nude photos of the women for the men to ogle and comment. They called prostitutes barbecue ribs, chocolate shakes, and other names. One Navy official asked Leonard for disease-free hookers.

Leonard Francis (20:01):
Well, you're a young dandy yandy man, you know. I mean, I'm used to orgies. That's my specialty.

Tom Wright (20:14):
Back then, Leonard was soaring high. In the post-9/11 years, he organized lavish dinners for officers of the biggest aircraft carriers in places like Hong Kong and Singapore. The dinners, often in Michelin-starred restaurants, cost $1,000 per plate. Afterward, officers smoked $2,000 a box Cohiba cigars and $2,000 a bottle cognac, and often they slept with prostitutes. He also took care of the grunts when they got into trouble in bars in far-flung ports.

Leonard Francis (20:53):
Yeah, so that's how we would get somebody out of jail. That's a quick fix, you know, damage control before the press gets a hold of

Tom Wright (21:04):
And GDMA was involved in that?

Leonard Francis (21:06):
Oh, we were involved in everything. We had—

Tom Wright (21:10):
Just give me an example of something like that. Like some— what would happen?

Leonard Francis (21:13):
Well, like, you know, molestation, bar fights, damages, you know, accidents, rape, anything.

Tom Wright (21:22):
Can you think of a specific rape allegation where GDMA played a role?

Leonard Francis (21:26):
For example, you know, sailors would be in pubs or in clubs, and then they would just go and, you know, rub a female the wrong way, you know, touch their breasts. So that's They're going to get arrested. Sometimes, you know, the girls are just not going to give in. You know, these guys get drunk, they get very boisterous, they start touching women. And then once you start touching someone who is like a university, going to become an attorney, she's going to yell rape on you, you know, molestation. And then the cops will come in and haul you in.

Tom Wright (21:58):
And that would happen.

Leonard Francis (21:59):
Well, then we have to go and, you know, resolve it and get the girl to withdraw the charges.

Tom Wright (22:04):
So GDMA would play that role in multiple occasions?

Leonard Francis (22:07):
Yes, yes, we played our roles in molestation and rape cases.

Tom Wright (22:13):
And that would involve paying off the local police, right?

Leonard Francis (22:15):
Well, not just the, the victims.

Tom Wright (22:18):
Just pay them off, keep it quiet.

Leonard Francis (22:20):
Yeah, well, just pay them off, right? Well, before we get to court, before we get to the press. I think what they try to prevent is, you know, coming out in the open.

Tom Wright (22:32):
So why don't you start by telling me about the genesis of this problem in the military? Where does it come from, and why, in your view, hasn't it been dealt with?

Don Christensen (22:42):
Yeah, that's an excellent question.

Tom Wright (22:44):
Don Christensen, the U.S. Air Force's former top prosecutor, is now president of Protect Our Defenders, a nonprofit that advocates for victims of sexual assault in the military. To be clear, no one in the Fat Leonard case has been accused of sexual assault. But as Don points out, the clear misogyny in the Navy creates a culture in which violence against women can thrive.

Don Christensen (23:08):
We know from the numbers that about 20,000 Men and women are sexually assaulted every year on the active duty force. About 13,000 of them are women, about 7,000 are men. So it affects both sexes, but it disproportionately affects women.

Tom Wright (23:24):
Don is 6 feet tall and talks about the military with a resignation born from experience. 7 years ago, he left the Air Force in disgust because of the military's failure to address sexual assault. And its opposition to reform.

Don Christensen (23:40):
Well, it wasn't an immediate decision. It was something that occurred over a number of years where I'd become frustrated with the justice system in the military that's controlled by commanders. Unlike the civilian world where police would do the investigation or FBI do an investigation and then arrest a person and charge them with a crime, and then the prosecutors would step in and look at it and and prosecute that crime. In the military, our investigative agencies don't arrest people. They don't charge them with crimes. They just do a report that goes to a commander, and that commander makes a decision whether a case should go forward or not. And the prosecutor doesn't. When I was the Chief Prosecutor of the Air Force, which sounds really cool to say, I was Chief Prosecutor of the Air Force, but I had virtually no authority. I had no ability to send any case to trial. That was completely a commander's decision.

Tom Wright (24:40):
The US military has its own legal system called the Uniform Code of Military Justice, and as Don said, a major issue for years has been that military commanders, not independent prosecutors, decide whether to go forward with sexual assault cases. That has meant many are thrown out.

Don Christensen (24:57):
One of my prosecutors had prosecuted a guy that had molested his 13-year-old mentally handicapped daughter and confessed to it, and his commander and first sergeant testified for him in findings to try to get him acquitted. And then after he was convicted, came in and testified that they wanted him to stay in the unit even though he was a convicted child molester. And I was like, wow. You know, what's going on here?

Tom Wright (25:29):
In 2012, Don successfully prosecuted a case involving a US Air Force F-16 pilot who was accused of sexually assaulting a civilian woman on a base in Italy. Don found the woman among the most credible victims he'd ever worked with in over 300 sexual assault cases. Pilot was sentenced by jury of officers to a year in jail and a dismissal that stripped him of his retirement benefits. But 3 months later, a senior commander concluded the evidence was insufficient. He determined that the pilot, whom he considered a doting father and husband, could never have committed the act, and he threw out the verdict.

Don Christensen (26:11):
They could care less about the victim, and it was kind of the last straw for me that the process needed to be changed, but I wasn't going to be able to do it from the inside.

Tom Wright (26:23):
Don left the Air Force in protest. Is it also the case that sexual crimes are somehow not seen as crimes in the culture?

Don Christensen (26:32):
I think across the military, it's viewed that a lot of the women who come forward are complaining they're out to get something, they're doing this for benefits, which there really aren't that many benefits, that they're out to get the guy. This was regret sex. So there's definitely that culture of disbelief that makes it difficult to get these cases to trial and to get convictions.

Tom Wright (26:57):
It's this very same military justice system that's dealing with many cases in the Fat Leonard scandal. As we'll hear, the Navy justice system is again coming up short. Leonard does deserve to go to jail, right?

Paula Coughlin (27:17):
Yeah.

Tom Wright (27:18):
I mean, he's pleaded guilty.

Paula Coughlin (27:19):
Oh yeah. Oh, definitely.

Tom Wright (27:21):
It's one thing to say that, okay, he was benefiting from a system of corruption and misogyny that existed, preexisted his arrival on the scene, but that doesn't mean that he's not guilty of all those crimes that he's pleaded guilty to.

Paula Coughlin (27:33):
He's monetized— he's monetized debauchery. And it's what, the oldest profession? He just really brought it into the 21st century. He just really made it an empire. He really made it lucrative.

Tom Wright (27:49):
Back in 1991, Paula dug in. She wrote a letter to the Navy, which was leaked to Senator John McCain, himself a former aviator. Who called for an investigation. A Defense Department probe found over 80 other women claimed they'd been victims of sexual assault or harassment at the Tailhook convention. The Navy also dug in. Because of the scale of the Tailhook scandal, the Navy set up what's called a Consolidated Disposition Authority, headed by an admiral, to administer justice. Prosecutors looked at 300 officers and 35 admirals but did not pursue a single court-martial. Some officers got censure letters or monetary fines in what amounted to a slap on the wrist. Many in Congress pushed back against this whitewash. In 1992, the Naval Criminal Investigative Service, or NCIS, was born under civilian leadership. You've probably heard of NCIS from the long-running TV show. But as you'll hear in coming episodes, it's nothing like the crack law enforcement agency portrayed on screen. And that's largely because ultimate prosecutorial power remained in the hands of Navy officers, as it does to this day. Paula resigned 4 years later, a figure of hate for what she had done. She sued the Hilton, was awarded a multimillion-dollar judgment, and reinvented herself as a yoga teacher. Today, as a board member of Protect Our Defenders, she's still involved in the fight for equality in the military. Going back to that woman who said she'd pray for you, I mean, you didn't talk to her husband, but I guess it's indicative of this idea that boys will be boys and you unnecessarily rocked the boat. Did you get a lot of that?

Paula Coughlin (29:37):
Oh, no, it's more specific than that. I ruined the Navy. That's pretty— wow. I mean, I'm 5'4", 120 pounds. I'm super fit and I'm smart, but I'm not enough of a resource to ruin the United States Navy.

Tom Wright (29:58):
The question now is, can Fat Leonard ruin the Navy? This podcast could do great damage. Why is Leonard even talking to us? In one sense, he's trying to blow up the institution and bring it down with him. He's bragging about the sexual misconduct at the heart of his fraud, at the same time exposing misogyny in the Navy. Leonard doesn't deny the corruption or the prurience, but in his view, everyone knew what was going on, and now the Navy's involved in a cover-up. It's hard not to agree. The Navy has failed, as during Tailhook, to hold its most senior admirals to account for their involvement with Leonard. This isn't a case of a few wrongdoers, but a systemic breakdown in a culture. In the next episode, we'll explore exactly why Leonard was so untouchable for so long. He didn't just provide prostitutes to admirals and pad contracts. Leonard's ability as an operator in the Pacific was second to none, and he was evolving to play a crucial national security role for the US. That's why he survived—no, thrived—despite the corruption. And as Leonard's star rose, Russian and Chinese spies started to circle around him.

Leonard Francis (31:30):
What really worried the United States the most was their officers being corrupted by me, that they would be corruptible by the foreign powers.

Tom Wright (31:47):
Fat Leonard is a production of Project Brazen in partnership with PRX. For Audiation, the executive producer is Sandy Smallens. Mark Lotto is the co-producer and story editor. The producer is Ireland Meacham. Mixing and sound design is by Matt Noble.

The audio is the record: this transcript may differ from it in small ways.

More transcripts from Fat Leonard

0:00